35. Panic! At the Disco
I Write Sins Not Tragedies
In some sense, it was wrong of us to brand the dudes of Panic! with the one hit wonder label. They have, after all, had considerable success on the Alternative Songs chart and have maintained a somewhat notable status within the alt-rock-pop-punk community many years after their first and only foray into the top ten of Billboard's Hot 100. Never-the-less, our participants have given "I Write Sins Not Tragedies" the dubious distinction of being the lowliest of one hit wonders assembled for the purpose of this rate-event-thing.
