Yes, she's been one of many.

Yes

Sort of she has ups and downs she's had flops and she's had smashes but one thing I've always found in her material is she always puts out some really great songs

Yea. The fact that shes still getting a top 10 and a #1 smash from her album ten years later is incredible, while some of the other main pop gurls on this thread are strugglin with it.

This is why I love Kelly; when she's here, she is a big player. When she's on break, that's what she does...BREAK.

I hate when artists over-saturate themselves by always being around all the time. But that's a reason, I guess, people always say they forget about Kelly. I never forget about her, and actually anticipate her return(s) every time.

No, call me when Stronger finally crosses that damn 1M mark

You'll be getting a call later this year then...?

No.

Of course

Not really. She has her moments but most people are only here for some of her songs.

Just like Rihanna hasn't crossed 1M yet.
Just like It took Katy how many singles to barely cross 2M.
Just like Gaga started with 1M, ended with 2M.
Just like Britney tapped out around 700K.

Where is your logic?

Nope. She might have a #1 but no one really cares about her.

Not really. She's like P!nk. Plenty of people love her but they dont see her as a serious threat or a main player. She kinda just exists.

Yeah it will, but her sales are still weak considering she had a multiweek #1 smash and a top 10.

She hasn't been a strong album seller since the end of the Breakaway era. Plain and simple.

This post is for Hooligan too

That doesn't answer the poll at all and is honestly irrelevant to the poll.

This.

No.

All those women have had some sort of other major success, though. Yeah Katy released 6 singles to sell 2m albums, but they sold in excess of 20m and she's apart of few albums to sell so many copies. Rih had "WFL", Gaga had her general hype, as Britney, plus their publicized tours and several hits (FF went way beyond 700k btw, sweetie).

Kelly got her generic little shine but she is way below the people you're trying to place with her. So much you should be embarrassed.