Nigel Lythgoe Calls Into TMZ: “It’s America’s Favorite Singer, Not America’s Best” (VIDEO)
Jessica shouldn't pick boring songs and he said she needs to show more personality.

I think Jessica shows personality.... :/
but song choices could be a bit better... oh well whatever, colton or philip will win... bleh

I agree with him saying Jessica should pick the right and popular songs and show more personality.

However it should be the best singer always, this isnt a pageant or popularity contest!

also what I mean for the best singer is someone who doesnt only sing great but also has the total package and Jessica fits that mold.


America should vote for the best tired of those teenage girls spamming the votes over those white guys.

Jlo just took her danm mic, she learned it from Nicole and Beyoncé...

Nigel should be asked of what does he thinks of the trend of white guys winning the show and what does he think of those teenage girls who votes non-stop to those who wets their pus.

I said THAT night (performance night) to my friend that Jessica was not going to win AI, and was going to be sent home. I just had that feeling. She is boring. She has a great voice but,A LOT of people do. There's nothing special about her. She can't perform well and engage the audience. She is only 16, so she has a lot of time to hone her skills.

sooooo basically he's saying if she chooses song that he likes and shows personality he and the other producer will keep her on the show...

I agree. I think that Jessica shouldn't be doing things that are Beyonce, but she should be doing things that are Jessica. And this is the reason why I kind of find her one-dimensional.

Lol he.comes after jessica for those reasons? I mean really hoe? Has he not seen what everyone is.performing? Shes the only that doesn't perform songs.from my grannys teenage years.