Beck The Information
Evanescence The Open Door
Jet Shine On
The Killers Sam's Town
George Strait It Just Comes Natural

Five heavy hitters all get released on the same day. Which one will come out on top of the heap?

And i'm going to make a big time case for George Strait here. He debuted in late 2004 at #1 with sales upwards of 350k, beating out Good Charlotte, Korn and a HUGE rerelease of Usher's "Confessions" with a double disc GREATEST HITS album. Do not discount him.

evanescence

i hope The Killers do

also Frankie J - Priceless I believe

I really hope Evanescence don't

The Killers or Beck would be good

Evanescence's sales will make out-trump the rest...(Which is basically a no brainer for most people)

Isnt this when Diddy & JoJo come out?

Nope, that's 2 weeks later on 10/17.

Evanescence has pretty much reserved #1 that week. Call Me When You're Sober seems to be faring much better than When You Were Young overall.

The Killers and JET. Buying both! Yes!

That time of year again, Super Tuesdays start popping up in Octoboer...

Evanescence, Killers, and Beck are all gonna make a run for #1. All will probably debut top 5 but if one doesn't, it'll be Jet.

01. Evanescence
02. George Strait
03. The Killers
04. Beck
05. Jet

1. The Killers Sam's Town
2. Beck The Information
3. Evanescence The Open Door
4. George Strait It Just Comes Natural
5. Jet Shine On

01 The Killers Sam's Town (hopefully)
02 Evanescence The Open Door
03 Beck The Information
04 George Strait It Just Comes Natural
05 Jet Shine On
06 Monica Makings Of Me

Evanescence is taking this crown y'all..They are way more superior than the Killers and their album is gaining more substantial buzz then Sam's Town..

Monica

lfr. are you serious?

Not to say that the Killers is getting more pre-impact "buzz" than the Evanescence, but in no way is "The Open Door" generating that much hype.

It's going to be a busy day though.

My predictions:

George Strait - #1 - 450k
The Killers - #2 - 425k
Evanescence - #3 - 350k
Beck - #4 - 175k
Jet - 100k

Evanescence - 450k
George Strait - 50k
The Killers - 125k
Beck - 175k
Jet - 100k

50K?! LMFAO. You think Jet's going to outsell one of the biggest country music stars of all time?

Alright, when he debuts in the top 3 along with The Killers and Evanescence, then we'll see.

Even his 125k prediction for The Killers is laughable.
I know we're all entitled to opinions, but c'mon now.

Evanescence or The Killers i think