Originally posted by Seymour_Omnis

The last three Britney videos did not retire because they weren't successful on the charts, so people weren't as willing to vote for them.

Originally posted by Anthony Kerty

That's not fair. MP was released in September, while SUBG was released around November. Plus, like I said before, Britney simply didn't care about her GH singles, while Kelly was promoting like hell her sophomore album.
And Fighter peaked 16 days at #1, against Miss Independent's 14 days on the top, in the end that's all that matter, who got more days at #1, not who got more days at Top 5 or whatsoever. Even so as far as I can remember Fighter was dominating the countdown until its 35-40th, when it started to chart lower than Top 3.

Originally posted by Seymour_Omnis

But that's not what I'm talking about. I'm talking about who will be in a higher position while they're both on the countdown.

Originally posted by Anthony Kerty

You clearly didn't get my point. :-/ Let's see them both releasing videos at the same day and then we can talk. I bet that if MP and SUBG had been released at the same time, charting together since then, Britney should have charted higher more days.
If you still don't understand, let's say again: Britney's video was already going down, it was on the countdown for more than 30 days, while SUGB was, how can I say, "brand new", justing getting started.

Originally posted by Seymour_Omnis

That didn't stop Sometimes from charting higher than the newer videos Genie in a Bottle and If You Had My Love .

Originally posted by Anthony Kerty

As far as I know, Genie In A Bottle was #1 for 7 days, and Sometimes peaked at #2. J.Lo's video are not on topic here. Anywayz, your point is a bit stupid, unless a video spends all days at #1 it will, eventually, chart lower than other videos. I think you're saying non-sense things and already got lost on that. Stop and think about this "chart higher" thing, it's totally freaky. :-/

Originally posted by Seymour_Omnis

Genie in a Bottle peaked at #2 and Sometimes made it to #1 once or twice.

Originally posted by Anthony Kerty

Oh yeah, Aguilera's #1s were What A Girl Wants and Come On Over Baby, each spent 7 days on top. But still, Sometimes didn't reach the top spot, not even for a day.