There's no massive dislike.

madonnas commented on how he found the songs, Kelly's ballads, to be. He found them to be without merit. I don't agree (in the case of Because of You), but he stated it as simply and non-inflammatorily as possible.

Taipen immediately went to flamebait. He said things that were no mere counterpoint, they were said to start arguments.

I did gwen and kelly last week and I can't for the life of me get through Mariah's album. I'm going to give it another try tonight. I don't think I should have done it coming off the last few uneventful tracks on breakaway..

Done
Breakaway - 9.3
L.A.M.B - 7.8
MiMi - 7.4
Dance Floor - 6.5

I have to thank Breakaway for introducing me to pop music, sorry. I thought Gwen's score would be a 8.5 wtf did I do!

This rate was really easy too cause I heard all the albums before atleast twice.

I can't remember my exact rates so I can't calculate the score.... but I think Confessions is somewhere between 9 and 10, LAMB between 8 and 9, Breakaway between 6.5 and 7.5 and Mimi between 6 and 7.

Breakaway deserves above a 7

I expected its average to be from 4-5, so it was definitely not as bad as I thought. A few 3 or lower songs, mostly 7-8s though....

Did you give you know what the 10 it deserves

Danger Zone for top 5.

I put on my impartial listening ears and my averages were:

L.A.M.B. - 6.516
Not as amazing as everyone likes to say. She's got a few flawless tracks ala Cool and then some downright garbage, eg Harajuku Girls


Breakaway - 6.333
This album really just drags on towards the end, I could barely make it through. Not here for it.

Emancipation - 7.692
Definitely the best album of the lot, and this is not the stan in me. I Love New York, Harajuku Girls, and I Hate Myself For Losing You handed Emancipation the highest rate.


Confessions - 7.433
Best tracks were Push, Jump, Forbidden Love, LIORN, and one or two others. I can't stand Madonna, her music, or her stans, but she was second for me in this rate.

6 of the 12 are really good, 2 are average, the other 4 = trash.

SENT!

Best songs from LAMB:
What You Waiting For?
Cool
Luxurious

Best songs from Breakaway:
Breakaway
Since You Been Gone
Behind These Hazel Eyes

Best songs from Emancipation:
Mine Again
Stay The Night
Shake it Off
WBT

Best songs from Confessions:
Hung Up
Jump
Forbidden Love
Push

I was actually unimpressed with, "Isaac", I just can't get with the male Umm Kulthum-like backing vocals.

WTH went on in here the past 24 hours


movin on...i am now at 32 rates...i MIGHT start it early, but the soonest would be friday...but I still have about 4 more people that said that they will send in their rates...

All four of y'all, send in your rates! Let's get this going Friday!

Well...looks like it won't start till tomorrow night...or early Monday morning.

I have 33 rates in. Don't miss your chance

Finally doing this for real.

C'MON I'm ready!!

Kelly's album is trash.