Both releasing albums on the same day (October 3rd)....so who´s gonna get the top spot on Billboard?

Or am I crazy and will it be someone else?

Clearly I´ll say Ev, and their single debut on the BB Hot 100 just shows it.......number 25 for first week. Plus people underestimate just how big their fanbase is.

But who knows?

i would assume evanescence.. unless when you were young catches on

either way, i am curious to hear both albums

Evanescence *zillion arrows* The Killers
The Killers are nice but that's it. You can't compare Amy Lee to Brandon Flowers.

Evanescence is going to win this "battle", of course. But I think The Killers is better.

In terms of who will sell more albums, Evanescence probably will.

But in terms of quality, I don't think there is a way to determine that yet because The Killlers have only released one album before this one whereas Evanescence has put a few albums out. *shrugs* I'll wait until I hear Sam's Town to judge.

I'll be buying The Killers. This will be interesting though.

Evanescenceeeeeeee

I'm betting on Evanescence.

I was a little disappointed by When You Were Young... I'm not quite sure why, but I just wasn't feeling it like I did with some of the tracks from Hot Fuss.

I choose evanescence
This is always a good group and better than The Killers 4ever
Call me u're a sober can climb to #2 TRL but When u were young can't

I would choose my whole family dying in a hurricane over Evanscence

Evanescence...but I want The Killers to win it.

Evanescence.

The killers are going to suck this time.

Cracks me up.

Why on Earth do people think this is funny? OMG FROGGERT YOU'RE LIKE SO CONTROVERSIAL, LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL!!!!!!

Based on first singles, CMWYS >>>>>>>>>>> WYWY. Ev will likely beat The Killers in albums sales too.

Hopefully it runs in the family

I don't think either of them will take the top spot.

The Killers are way better

The Killers are WAYYYYY better

For once I half-way agree with Froggert

The Killers>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>E vanescence

Evanescence will top the charts, and yeah The Killers will probably debut at 7 or 8 if lucky.