VS.




If both half sisters (from charmed) were to get in a witch fight, who will win???

I like Prue more but probably Paige. Didn't she have like a bajillion powers?

Paige had advantages from being a half whitelighter. I think prue would have won (EXPERIENCE)

PRUE and ANDY!
How come moms and grandmas got to come back but Prue never did!?
And it was three sisters not three plus an extra one.
Ruined my favorite show.

Oh who would win, lmao

Prue would win.
As oldest she was the most powerful.
And her power was growing fast!

Prue the Almighty Halliwell.

Haha. There was some heat between Alyssa and Shannon. So, Alyssa threatened to leave the show if Shannon didn't. So, Shannon was asked to leave

No, she wasn't asked to leave. She left. It was her decision. It was her decision not to appear in any chapter + she banned the use of her image on the show. That's why there wasn't a single photo of her in the whole house

I love her, though. But she became boring as ****, and a bit ugly. Paige had all Prue lacked of.

I've always liked Prue better. Paige was trying too hard to belong and she isn't half as calculative as Prue

Why did she leave?? NOOOOOO!

She had problems with Alyssa because she was dating Cole (Shannen's ex) and also they had a big diva complex...but Alyssa never threatened her or the team. Shannen always had a huge ego, and she decided to left. She was a superstar back then, though.

Now...well. None of the four girls' career post-Charmed is remarkable, but I think Paige's or Piper's are the best.

Prue

Paige

I'm almost certain Shannon was fired because Alyssa and Shannon hated each other, Alyssa was the bigger draw (supposedly) so they dropped Shannon. A shame really because Shannon was the best dramatic actress the show had.

Paige is a more funny character prue is much better fighter.

Paige was cute, but Prue was LIFE.

Prue