Poll: More Disappointing: Born This Way or Give Me All Your Luvin'

MonsterNavy

Which is song is more disappointing?
Born This Way or Give Me All Your Luvin'?
Both are much anticipated comeback singles from 2 of the biggest female popstars of their own generations...

Discuss...
No fighting...
Keep it cute. I love both Madge and Gaga

UAE

Give Me All Your luvin'

HighwayHooker

If they were both released at the same time, it would be BTW, though now I have grown to like it. And I'm sure GMAYL will have the same outcome. But at the moment, GMAYL is the most disappointing

FAN

I don't know tbh, I really don't, I need more time.

Madonnas is way catchier, more generic, but way funner. No idea.

EOMM92

Born This Way.

That's all..

Edit: **** i voted for BTW i didn't read the OP before voting

But.. GMAYL is way more dissapointing.

Jameson Teqkilla

I found them both equally disappointing.

I just flat out don't like BTW. The lyrics are too cheesy, the production is way too much, and frankly, yes, the melody sounds like Express Yourself.

I also just don't like GMAYL. The lyrics are too cheesy, the production is way too little and sounds exactly like Hello, and both of the rappers were screwed over in their verse length to make room for some of the weakest, thinnest vocals Madge has ever delivered.

So I guess it's a tie!

Loghen

Give Me All Your Luvin'.

Forevermore

GMAYL

HaHa2011

Give Me All Your Luvin'

DitaBoy12

oh please can we let this die already?! why can we just like who we like and enjoy music?? I stan for Madonna but really like some gaga songs what is wrong with that?

tell_me_a_lie

I love BTW when I first heard it and for Madonna's, I expected more something that would top her powerful lead singles such as Hung Up and 4 minutes.

EDIT: BTW has more significant lyrics/message though.

XtremeSteel

Son of a b*****. Give Me All Your Love ***** on ur tricky poll.

IWasHere

GMAYL

Cz!

Did GMAYL disappoint anyone?

I mean, the demo's been out for a while now...

WarriorQueen

Born This Way. She hyped it up so much that I was expecting something amazing.
but they're both disappointing to say the least.

HighwayHooker

Quote:

Originally posted by DitaBoy12

oh please can we let this die already?! why can we just like who we like and enjoy music?? I stan for Madonna but really like some gaga songs what is wrong with that?

tell_me_a_lie

Quote:

Originally posted by IWasHere

The one with the senior citizen.

i spit on haters

I instantly voted for BTW without reading the thread because I assumed you were asking which song do we prefer...not which one is more disappointing.

MonsterMosama

Quote:

Originally posted by EOMM92

Edit: **** i voted for BTW i didn't read the OP before voting

.

+1

they need to make the title 'BIGGER DISAPPOINTMENT?: BTW VS GiveMeAllYourLuvin'

and born this way delivered completely for me. I almost cried the 1st time i heard it and was left slayed to bite sized pieces.

lancelovesgaga