mmm....yes....maybe this is Kelly's worst performance

probably

i dont know what happened to her that time...she was like singing too fast and not feeling the rhythm of the song...she really sucked...she is very good usually

I don't think so....she is always screaming when she sings

She can't sing live really

Sucked?

Kind of.
But I liked it. : D

Besides this one is 2-3 years old. And I know this line is used a lot, but it did sound/look as if she was sick.

But at least she gives a decent effort into giving a live performance unlike some other performers and bands.

which performance is it ? and song? i cant see the video

'miss independent' performance from mtv the dome germany

I thought it was good.. especially cause the song must be a bitch to sing

Hello...She can sing extremely well live. That's why she won American Idol after all.

It's when she tries to put the rock edge into it that she starts screaming.

American Idol = Artists without talent

ouch, she sort messed up. But so what, things like this sometimes happens. and im sure she got over it and moved on.

Unlike the Strokes, at least Kelly, Ruben, Fantasia, and Carrie are going to higher places in their musical careers.

And unless your referring to the idiots who audition for the show to begin with (Along with the several who filter through to later rounds), I'd like to see you to try and defend this statement any further.

Not all, the latest season of American Idol has very good talents. Kelly Clarkson, Clay Aiken, Carrie Underwood & Bo Bice are the best of American Idiol, in my opinion, but obviously, they are not perfect.

And... I like your avatar

i just realized that 'miss independent' is such a horrible song with no melody ...it's very boring

Ha, that's the funniest thing I've read all year.

Poor Kelly!!

It was funnier when you said Walk Away was a good video

That performance was eh

I like Miss Independent, but that performance just didn't seem good enough

i didn't think it was that bad... it was okay

Ok, I never said that