What was your first ATRL "hit" thread?


Must be at least 5 pages long to qualify
Only your first hit thread, not just your best


While we are at it, lets also make this into a point-based game.
Points will be awarded for certain criteria of the thread.


Here's how it goes:

a) 5 base points for the "hit" thread, so everyone will get starter 5 points
b) 1 extra point for each page after page #5 up to a maximum of 10 extra points.
c) 5 extra points if the thread wasn't locked by a mod [doesn't matter if it expired]
d) 1 to 5 points for effort: does it looks good, well presented, or just "x vs y. discuss"
e) 5 extra points if somebody got issued a warning point within the first 3 pages.
f) 5 extra points if one of the mods left a comment within the first 3 pages


Here's how you need to present it:

1. Name of your thread
2. Link to your thread
3. Quote of the warned comment (if any & if that's allowed)
4. Explanation of the points you awarded to yourself.
5. Total points earned







So let me start with mine:


1. BB Year-End Chart Predictions
2. http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=153971
3. No warning points

a) 5 base points
b) 7 pages long = 2 extra points
c) not locked = 5 extra points
d) awfully presented = 1 extra point
e) no one was warned = 0 points
f) no mod left a comment = 0 points

Total: 13 points

Originally posted by Robertlavigne Album vs Album Thread a)5 Base Points b)14 pages-9 extra points c)Terrible presented-1 extra point e)No one warned f)No mod left a comment Total=15 points http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=106156&page=1 I might start the Album vs Album thread again. It was very successful

1. Members you like
2. http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=147212
3. No WP's.

a) 5 base points
b) 13 pages long = 8 extra points
c) not locked = 5 extra points
d) badly presented = 1 extra point
e) no one was warned = 0 points
f) no mod left comment = 0 points

Originally posted by =NEX= you forgot point d). 5 points extra if it wasn't locked

Originally posted by Rentboy How many posts is per page? Dont people have different settings? I mean my biggest thread(Ive only started about 5) had 104 replies but it seems thats not a hit by your reckoning.

Originally posted by rihannafan yesterday with the versatile voice thread and the best part is that it wasn't a stan war and i wasn't aiming for a hit thread a) 5 base points for the "hit" thread, so everyone will get starter 5 points = 5 b) 1 extra point for each page after page #5 up to a maximum of 10 extra points. = 10 c) 5 extra points if the thread wasn't locked by a mod [doesn't matter if it expired] = 5 d) 1 to 5 points for effort: does it looks good, well presented, or just "x vs y. discuss" = 5 e) 5 extra points if somebody got issued a warning point within the first 3 pages.=0 f) 5 extra points if one of the mods left a comment within the first 3 pages =0 =25

Originally posted by =NEX= link?

Originally posted by Doc Since there seems to be varying opinions here on ATRL, answer the question and keep it cute.