TV Show: American Idol panel on their competition - Page 4

Patrick

Quote:

Originally posted by RobynYoBank

2

Exactly. 2. Their track record for producing "global superstars" isn't something they should be bragging about.

tj hazuki

Quote:

Originally posted by Patrick

Everybody that's still associated with this sinking ship is so bitter.

Sure, take a jab at Leona for her shortlived relevance in the states, but how many former Idol contestants have managed to sustain successful careers in the US, much less internationally?

Can name about four top of my head in the US that is excluding Kelly
Jennifer Hudson
Carrie Underwood
Chris Daughtry
Fantasia

And David Cook had one big album era. He sadly flopped next album though. Scotty McCcerry could be the male Carrie Underwood in the Country genre. Poised to have a very good career in that genre. He's almost platinum in his first album. Katharine McPhee, if all goes well in her new show, could be very successful in the upcoming year.

Kelly is the only international star they've produced/discovered. Maybe expect Daughtry? The potential with Lambert is their. X Factor has only produced Leona as an internationally star, and some local stars (Olly Murs, JLS, etc) The Voice? not so much as of yet.

tell_me_a_lie

Quote:

Originally posted by hazuki

Can name about five top of my head in the US that is excluding Kelly
Jennifer Hudson
Carrie Underwood
Chris Daughtry
Fantasia
Kelly Clarkson

Kelly is the only international star they've produced/discovered. Maybe expect Daughtry?

Jennifer is also popular worldwide. Kelly is the most successful internationally followed by daughtry then jordin then jennifer

Wkayz

Quote:

Originally posted by North & South

American Idol Panel at the Television Critics Association:

...

- "Leona Lewis was kind of a one-and-a-half hit star for 10 minutes. . . this is the show that produces the stars." — producer Ken Warwick, on why he thinks American Idol is the best of the genre
ouder,” compared to #Idol. Idol is the “gold standard,” he says.

...

Sapphire

they are so bitter esp for Randy
backlashing The Voice

pay no respect at all to them...

Superbitch

How ignorant he sounds tbh. Like as if idol is the.only singing competition that should be shown on TV. And what big stars has the show produced?

Kelly, Carrie, Jennifer......hew else?

In 10 years!!!

And if girls don't win is because they always overhype n don't criticize the guys like they should...just ask Haley reinhart

Superbitch

Quote:

Originally posted by hazuki

Can name about four top of my head in the US that is excluding Kelly
Jennifer Hudson
Carrie Underwood
Chris Daughtry
Fantasia

And David Cook had one big album era. He sadly flopped next album though. Scotty McCcerry could be the male Carrie Underwood in the Country genre. Poised to have a very good career in that genre. He's almost platinum in his first album. Katharine McPhee, if all goes well in her new show, could be very successful in the upcoming year.

Kelly is the only international star they've produced/discovered. Maybe expect Daughtry? The potential with Lambert is their. X Factor has only produced Leona as an internationally star, and some local stars (Olly Murs, JLS, etc) The Voice? not so much as of yet.

At least the x factor UK produces big stars even if they remain local. They sell n they become famous because they also focus in star quality. Unlike idol. Takes ppl with no personally and over hypes them I almost died last year when that Adam L rip off was being over hyped by Randy cuz he wanted him to win.

n he was terrible. Idol can't even give us big local stars! Oh well, at least the show is OK.

Sept

what they said it's true though
Javier's album debuted #134 Billboard
Dia's album can't even crack into top 200 Billboard
it's a damn shame

i can't @ those xtina stans acting like The Voice is the most successful singing competition

Superbitch

Quote:

Originally posted by Sept

what they said it's true though
Javier's album debuted #134 Billboard
Dia's album can't even crack into top 200 Billboard
it's a damn shame

i can't @ those xtina stans acting like The Voice is the most successful singing competition

Lol I knew it. I enjoyed the show but not that much tbh. I couldn't stand most of the contestants especially all those older ppl. And none if them looked like a star -Dia but I guess she flopped too

not surprised.

ifyouseekLEM

Quote:

Originally posted by North & South

- "Leona Lewis was kind of a one-and-a-half hit star for 10 minutes. . . this is the show that produces the stars." — producer Ken Warwick, on why he thinks American Idol is the best of the genre

Source: http://www.mjsbigblog.com/american-i...anel-recap.htm

Clock ha!

Kedzie53

Quote:

Originally posted by RobynYoBank

But how many successful singing shows were they before Idol?

Quote:

We're the original, we kind of invented this whole game that everybody's now copying." — Jackson, on the profusion of singing reality shows

He doesn't mention anything about success but basically the concept.

Lipton

They really punched Leona.

Kedzie53

Quote:

Originally posted by Sept

what they said it's true though
Javier's album debuted #134 Billboard
Dia's album can't even crack into top 200 Billboard
it's a damn shame

i can't @ those xtina stans acting like The Voice is the most successful singing competition

No one is saying that. The people of American Idol shouldn't be acting like cocky pricks who think that American Idol was the first of its kind and just go around insulting other people.

tj hazuki

Another Idol contestant signed to a label. Chris Richardson of season 6 signed to Young Money/Cash Money (

) he could pretty popular too...

Errrlend

Katherine McPhee is auditioning for The Voice?
DYING. She was like, 2nd on idol agains Tyler ~~FLOP~~ Hicks

HaHa2011

These bitches down @ AI are pressed aren't they lol. I really don't appreciate the Leona shade.

DejaVu

Quote:

Originally posted by Errrlend

Katherine McPhee is auditioning for The Voice?
DYING. She was like, 2nd on idol agains Tyler ~~FLOP~~ Hicks

Where'd you read that? As far as I know, she's already busy with her show on NBC.

Graduation

Quote:

Originally posted by Ace Reject

This is all Randy has. Notice how the other two judges and the host - who all have more than THIS - weren't around to trash talk?

AND he's the only remaining judge from the beginning of the show. He has more of an interest in the show succeeding than anyone else at this point, although he is a great studio session bassist.

It says a lot that he's this bothered over The Voice, which has had only 1 season thus far and hasn't delivered a huge star like Kelly Clarkson in year 1 of American Idol. He sees the show is slipping.