Album tracks really show if an album is a cohesive body of work or not. The singles on many albums are the only strong tracks, while album tracks remain weak an unimportant. If an album is about showcasing a particular artist's talent, image, and artistry, then all tracks on the album should be strong and pertinent. In this thread we will decide based solely on the album tracks of particular records if they measure up against another album.
WINNERS
1. The Fame [34] vs One on the Boys [19]
1. 2008 Debuts
One of the Boys Album Tracks
1. "One of the Boys"
6. "Ur So Gay"
8. "If You Can Afford Me"
9. "Lost"
10. "Self Inflicted"
11. "I'm Still Breathing"
12. "Fingerprints"
The Fame Album Tracks
6. "Beautiful, Dirty, Rich"
7. "The Fame"
8. "Money Honey"
9. "Starstruck" (featuring Space Cowboy and Flo Rida)
10. "Boys Boys Boys"
11. "Paper Gangsta"
12. "Brown Eyes"
13. "I Like It Rough"
14. "Summerboy"
2. 2009 Dark Pop
The Fame Monster Album Tracks
3. "Monster"
4. "Speechless"
5. "Dance in the Dark"
7. "So Happy I Could Die"
8. "Teeth"
Rated R Album Tracks
1. "Mad House"
2. "Wait Your Turn"
4. "Stupid in Love"
7. "Fire Bomb"
9. "Photographs" (featuring will.i.am)
10. "G4L"
12. "Cold Case Love"
13. "The Last Song"
I loved the singles from both albums, but The Fame is suppreme for me and I liked all the songs of the album too and that's not the case with OOTB, that's what made me a stan in the first place, so I choose THE FAME.