Quote:
|
Originally posted by Exodus
This year was horrid to me. Kevin Covais and Taylor Hicks are a waste of space. Ayla deserved this and her spot was certainly wasted.
|
I don't think this year was horrid, but I do also think Kevin & Taylor were wasted space. I also claim Lisa as a waste after the semis. I'd rather have seen Gideon, Ayla, and maybe Patrick in their places.
As for this list of Tracks
1. Kevin - His only good performance - But he DOESN'T deserve his spot on the CD. But Good Choice
2. Melissa - Her BEST performance, and one of my favorites of the season GReat Choice
3. Lisa - I'll be skipping this one, that performance with exception of the last 5 seconds was cabert/Karaeoke Ker-ap. Terrible choice.
4. Mandisa - I had an idea that one would be in place. Good Choice
5. Bucky - OK Choice... but I'd rather have the Tim McGraw track he did.
6. Paris - Good choice, but if they could, they should put her standards performance
7. Ace - Decent Choice - Just OK
8. Katherine - Good Choice - This was the performance that made me first forsee her in the top 12, and a likely contender for the final 4.
9. Kellie - Wrong Choice - Try "I'm the only one"; that one was her best.
10. Chris - OK Choice - But Hemmoragh is wayyyyy better.
11. Taylor - Dunno, Don't Care - The dude is more of a show-stage performer than a recording artist. But I guess this one might be OK. `_`.
12. Elliot - Good Choice, very good.
