'The Fame', 'The Fame Monster' and 'Born This Way' each have a piano-driven power ballad.
So, tell me. Which is your favourite out of the three?

The Fame: "Brown Eyes"
The Fame Monster: "Speechless"
Born This Way: "Yoü and I"

Assuming we're going with the studio versions-
You And I > Brown Eyes > Speechless

Assuming we're going with the acoustic versions-
You And I > Speechless > Brown Eyes

Speechless > You & I > Brown Eyes

I don't like any of them. But if I had to choose, i'd go with Brown eyes.
She needs proper ballads, no these power ballads nonsense

Speechless>>Yoü and I>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Brown Eyes

The first two are good; Brown Eyes is easily the worst song on The Fame.

Speechless > You and I > Brown Eyes

Speechless > Brown Eyes > You & I

You & I >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Brown Eyes

Speechless > Brown Eyes = You and I

Speechless, definitely. It's emotional without being cheesy, and is performed the best live.

You and I!!

Nebraska, i'd rather die!!!!!

Yoü and I

Speechless

You and I by default. The other ones are just bad, bad songs. You and I can be altered and then be made listenable. The same can't be said for the other two.

Brown Eyes > Speechless >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Judas >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> You & I

I think a lot of people are choosing "Yoü and I" because it was a single and it is the most recent of the three.
My personal favourite is "Brown Eyes" which sounds like it was inspired by Queen or something. I love the intro too!