You guys can follow my lead, or do something different? Also, if you can remember, put your favorite performance by them!

Love[d]
1. Kelly Clarkson (You're All I Need to Get By)
2. Tamyra Grey (Feel the Fire)
3. Fantasia (Summertime, the first time it was performed)
4. Kimberley Locke (Again, Somewhere Over the Rainbow number one)
5. Carrie Underwood (MacArthur Park)
6. Carmen Rasmussen (*shut up Mikal!) [Love Will Lead You Back]

Really Like[d]
7. Paris Bennett (Foolish Things)
8. Elliot Yamin (Somebody to Love)
9. Katharine McPhee (Until You Come Back to Me?)
10. Trenyce (a.k.a. LaShundra Cobbs)[Let's Stay Together]

Like[d]
11. LaToya London (but as I was writing this, I totally forgot about her? LMAO) (Don't Rain on My Parade)
12. Diana Degarmo (Don't Cry Out Loud)
13. Vonzell Solomon
14. John Stevens
15. Christina Christian
16. Ruben Studdard
17. Constantine Maroulis (I Can't Make You Love Me)

Was/Am Indifferent To
18. Nikki McKibbin
19. Bo Bice
20. Chris Daughtry
21. Clay Aiken
22. Justin Guarini

Dislike[d]
23. Anthony Federov
24. Josh Gracin
25. George Huff
26. RJ Helton

Hate[d]/Loathe[d]
27. Taylor Hicks
28. Scott Savol
29. Jasmine Trias
30. Kellie Pickler

1. Kelly Clarkson (SLTT, obviously, so I say Don't Play That Song)
2. Kimberley Locke (New York State Of Mind)
3. Tamyra Grey (Minnie The Moocher)
4. George Huff (You gotta love his bounce ^_^)
5. Trenyce (Come See About Me)
6. Bo Bice (Whipping Post)
7. Paris Bennett (Foolish Things)
8. Vonzell Solomon (Best Of My Love)
9. Carrie Underwood (Hello, Young Lovers)
10. Fantasia (Always On My Mind)
11. Elliot Yamin
12. LaToya London (All By Myself)
13. Diana Degarmo
14. Katharine McPhee (Until You Come Back to Me)
15. Christina Christian (At Last)
16. Ruben Studdard
17. Nikki McKibbin (Hard-Hearted Hannah)
18. Chris Daughtry (Hemmorage)
19. Clay Aiken
20. Justin Guarini (Sunny)
21. Anthony Federov
22. RJ Helton
23. Taylor Hicks
24. Scott Savol
25. Carmen Rasmussen (Bart went mad, I say )
26. Jasmine Trias (but I really did like Inseperable)
27. Josh Gracin
28. Kellie Pickler
29. Constantine Maroulis
30. John Stevens

Based only on performances on the show

1. Diana DeGarmo (Don't Cry Out Loud)
2. Fantasia Barrino (Summertime)
3. Kelly Clarkson
4. Paris Bennett
5. LaToya London (Somewhere)
6. Vonzell Solomon
7. Carrie Underwood (Alone)
8. Jasmine Trias (Inseparable)
9. Anthony Fedorov (I Surrender)
10. Kellie Pickler
11. Elliott Yamin
12. Chris Daughtry
13. Clay Aiken
14. George Huff (Against All Odds)
15. Katharine McPhee
16. Taylor Hicks
17. Ruben Studdard
18. Bo Bice
19. John Stevens (Crocodile Rock)
20. Constantine Maroulis
21. Scott Savol

Haven't heard enough of:
Tamyra Grey
Kimberley Locke
Carmen Rasmussen
Trenyce
Christina Christian
Nikki McKibbin
Justin Guarini
Josh Gracin
RJ Helton

Liked:
-Ryan Starr
-Tamyra Gray
-Diana DeGarmo
-Carrie Underwood
-Bo Bice
-Camile Velasco
-Jennifer Hudson
-Kellie Pickler
-Katharine McPhee

01. Diana Degarmo (I loved all of her performances)
02. Kelly Clarkson (I Surrender)
03. Tamyra Grey (House Is Not A Home)
04. Kimberley Locke (Band Of Gold)
05. LaToya London (All By Myself)
06. Vonzell Solomon (I Turn To You)
07. Paris Bennett (Wind Beneath My Wings)
08. Carrie Underwood (MacArthur Park, Crying)
09. Trenyce (Let's Stay Together)
10. Nikki McKibbin (Mary Jane, Heartbreaker)
11. Jasmine Trias (Inseperable)
12. Carmen Rasmussen (Turn the Beat Around, Love Will Lead You Back)
13. Elliot Yamin (Somebody to Love)
14. Katharine McPhee (Who Wants To Live Forever)
15. Christina Christian (Ain't No Sunshine)
16. Ruben Studdard (Superstar)
20. Chris Daughtry (What A Wonderful World)
21. Josh Gracin
22. Fantasia (Summertime)
23. Justin Guarini
24. Bo Bice
25. George Huff
26. RJ Helton
27. Anthony Federov
28. Kellie Pickler
29. Constantine Maroulis
30. John Stevens
31. Taylor Hicks
32. Scott Savol
33. Clay Aiken


Color Code
The one I will be obsessed with forever, and will always be my favorite.
Great!!!
Good
Ehh
Horrible, Horrible, Awful!! Sucktastic!

I didn't see season 1 or 2 soooo...I'll do 3, 4, and 5.

Loved:
1) Vonzell Solomon (I Have Nothing)
2) Katharine McPhee (Until You Come Back To Me)
3) Paris Bennett (Fever)

Liked:
4) Latoya London
5) Elliot Yamin (Somebody To Love, or whatever song he did 2nd week of Semis)
6) Fantasia Barrino (Holding Out For A Hero, I guess. The other ones I remember were kind of boring.)

Meh:
7) Constantine Maroulis (My Funny Valentine)
8) Chris Daughtry (Innuendo or Hemmorage)
9) Diana Degarmo
10) Anthony Federov

Disliked:
11) Bo Bice
12) Jasmine Trias (Some song she sang during Barry Manilow week)
13) Scott Savol (Everlasting Love)
14) George Huff

Loathed:
15) Kellie Pickler (Let's Give Them Something To Talk About?)
16) Carrie Underwood (Hello, Young Lovers)
17) John Stevens - I remember his performances, I just don't have a favorite because they all brought on some major suckage.
18) Taylor Hicks - ^

This season's Top 6 is actually not half bad, at least they got rid of the bulk of the suckage early on. But overall, I can say at least 1 bad thing about all of them.

Liked: - In no real order -
S1:
Kelly Clarkson (Without You / Natural Women / Stuff Like that there)
Tamyra Gray (House is not a home / Raindrops will fall / Star)
Nikki McKibben (Black Velvet)

S2:
Reuben Studdard (Flying without Wings/Signed Sealed Delivered along with several others)
Kimberly Locke (New York State of Mind)
Trenyce (Power Of Love / Some whitney Houstan Song)

S3:
Fantasia: (Give them somethin to talk about, Summertime, I believe)
Diana (Dreams, and that one song where she held a long note at the end)
Latoya London (Her explosive elimenation exiting of "Don't rain on my Parade" with the roaring ovation / Ain't Nobody / Somebody saved my life)
George Huff

S4: (Didn't watch) - (But caught the "Best of" DVD)
Bo Bice (I don't wanna be / Whipping Post / Sweet Home Alabama)
Carrie Underwood (Wanna be inside you heaven / Alone / Making love out of nothing at all)
Constantine (Funny Valentine)

S5:
Katherine McPhee - (Freedom, Bringing out the elvis in me, and a couple others)
Kellie Pickler - (I'm the only one)
Paris B - (Fever / Show must go on)
Elliot - (I don't wanna be / Moody's Mood / Standards performance)
Chris Daughtry - (Pretty much everything he's done. He rocks. )

I am going to have a hard time ranking them, so I will just simple categorize the ones I liked:

LOVED:
01.Kelly Clarkson (1)
02.Tamyra Gray (1)
03.Kimberley Locke (2)
04.Diana Degarmo (3)
05.Carrie Underwood (4)
06.Vonzell Soloman (4)

Really LIKED:
01.Christina Christian (1)
02.Clay Aiken (2)
03.Josh Gracin (2)
04.Trenyce (2)
05.Latoya London (3)
06.Katherine McPhee (5)

Liked:
01.Ruben Studdard (2)
02.Fantasia (3)
03.Jasmine Trias (3)
04.Anthony Federov (4)
05.Chris Daughtry (5)
06.Paris Bennett (5)

Yeah...it's been real sporadic with the season...season 5 being the weakest by far so far though. uh. Anyhow, I would like to give a special mention for Jessica Sierra (4) and Lisa Tucker (5), who I also though were excellent, but lost early. = (

1. Kelly Clarkson - I liked Tamyra better during the show. Now I like Kelly MUCH better! One of my favorite AI's

2. Kimberley Locke - Didn't really liike her

3. Tamyra Grey - MY GIRL!!! Loved her on the show! She is trying to make a name for herself noe though. I seen her in quite a few movies.

4. George Huff - He was okay. Definately not one of my favorites though

5. Trenyce - My favorite during her season

6. Bo Bice - Never really got into him

7. Paris Bennett - My favorite this season

8. Vonzell Solomon - My favorite during her season

9. Carrie Underwood - Never really liked her. Upset that she won

10. Fantasia - My absolute favorite AI of all time!!!

11. Elliot Yamin - Don't really like him

12. LaToya London - Beautiful voice. I actually liked her better than Fantasia during their season. It's definately vise versa now!

13. Diana Degarmo - HATED HER!! Completely no competition for Fantasia

14. Katharine McPhee - She's cool, I loved her in the beginning. She's really marketable. In fact, as I've said before, she the most marketable of all the remaining AI contestants this season. However, I don't like her voice.

15. Christina Christian - I used to think she was really hot! Haven't seen much of her lately! She was okay. Nothing special

16. Ruben Studdard - He was cool in the beginning. But then his performances started to get really repetitive toward the end. He had some sucess though post AI. I just was never really drawn to his music.

17. Nikki McKibbin - I was so pissed when she stayed over Tamyra during the 1st season! I have nothing positive to say about her!

18. Chris Daughtry - If this is the Rock & Roll Chris from this season. Then no, don't really like him!

19. Clay Aiken - HATED HIM! He was so ----ing gay!!!! And his broadway voice makes me so mad!

20. Justin Guarini - Didn't like him

21. Anthony Federov - Don't remember him

22. RJ Helton - I kinda remember him. Wasn't a big fan of his though

23. Taylor Hicks - Really liked him in the beginning, now he's just BLAH!

24. Scott Savol - Don't remember him

25. Carmen Rasmussen - Refer to above

26. Jasmine Trias - Her first performance was really good. Then she just went downhill from there

27. Josh Gracin - wasn't a fan

28. Kellie Pickler - She has her shining moments.I can't say that I don't like her

29. Constantine Maroulis - wasn't a fan

30. John Stevens - is this that red headed dude that everyone hated on season 3.... HATED HIM!!!!!

Loved loved loved
1. Katharine McPhee [Since I Fell For You/Someone Watching Over Me]
2. Kelly Clarkson [Natural Woman (I love me some high notes)]
3. Vonzell Solomon [I Have Nothing]
4. Christina Christian [Ain't No Sunshine]

Liked a lot
5. Kimberley Locke ?
6. Tamyra Grey ?
7. Elliot Yamin [Somebody To Love]
8. LaToya London ?
9. Trenyce ?

Liked
10. Chris Daughtry [Hemmorhage (In My Hands)]
11. Jasmine Trias ?
12. Paris Bennett [Midnight Train To Georgia]
13. Diana Degarmo ?
14. Bo Bice [I Don't Want To Be]

Kinda like
15. Taylor Hicks [Whatever last week's performance was]
16. Nikki McKibbin [Total Eclipse of the Heart]
17. Carrie Underwood [Alone]
18. Carmen Rasmussen ?

Just ok...
19. Anthony Federov [Incomplete]
20. Fantasia [Summertime]
21. Clay Aiken [Bridge Over Troubled Water]

The rest I can't rate since I never liked a single performance...
John Stevens
Constantine Maroulis
Ruben Studdard
Justin Guarini
George Huff
RJ Helton
Josh Gracin
Scott Savol
Kellie Pickler

People I really liekd that missed out:
Jennifer Hudson

1. Kelly Clarkson (1)
2. Bo Bice (4)
3. Vonzell Solomon (4)
4. Trenyce (2)
5. Fantasia Burrino (3)
6. Kimberley Locke (2)
7. Carrie Underwood (4)
8. Taylor Hicks (5)
9. Clay Aiken (2)
10. Paris Bennett (5)
11. Josh Gracin (2)
12. Jasmine Trias (3)
13. Katharine McPhee (5)
14. Tamyra Grey (1)
15. Diana Degarmo (3)
16. Nikki McKibbin (1)
17. Elliot Yamin (5)
18. Christina Christian (1)
19. Chris Daughtry (5)
20. Carmen Rasmussen (3)
21. RJ Helton (1)
22. Kellie Pickler (5)
23. LaToya London (2)
24. Ruben Studdard (2)
25. Justin Guarini (1)
26. Anthony Federov (4)
27. George Huff (3)
28. John Stevens (3)
29. Constantine Maroulis (4)
30. Scott Savol (4)

Favorites in no real order:

Kelly Clarkson
Vonzell Solomon
Trenyce
Paris Bennett
Tamyra Grey
LaToya London

My favorites have always been the girls.