Katy had the better single choices though Rihanna's songs overall are better.

I prefer Rihanna's, but Katy Perry was way more succesful

Only Girl (In the World) - California Gurls (neither)
What's My Name - Teenage Dream (neither)
S&M - Firework
California King Bed - E.T. (both)
Man Down - Last Friday Night (neither)
Cheers (Drink to That) - The One That Got Away (both)


Katy had a more successful single era and I prefer her music tbh

I mean it's not like I use her a lot, but I like the bolder singles above + the unreleased gem that is Circle the Drain

I don't use/like much of rihs music period

Only Girl > California Gurls
What's My Name? > Teenage Dream
S&M > Firework
California King Bed < E.T.
Man Down >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F.)
Cheers (Drink To That) > The One That Got Away

If you're talking about singles success obviously Katy had that in the US. However, Rihanna's singles are better than Katy's.

Katy's were better chioces and much more successful.

that doesnt change the fact that OG was discounted and S&M was remixed with GODNEY spears. i love rihanna but discounting the first single ... is just

Only Girl (In the World) - California Gurls
What's My Name - Teenage Dream

S&M - Firework

California King Bed - E.T.

Man Down - Last Friday Night
Cheers (Drink to That) - The One That Got Away

Rihanna-4
Katy-3

So Rihanna wins, and I like her better overall

Teenage Dream.

Only Girl (In The World) - California Gurls
What's My Name - Teenage Dream
S&M - Firework
California King Bed - E.T.
Man Down - Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F.)
Cheers (Drink To That) - The One That Got Away

+1


This isn't about what you like more, this is about what was more successful. Anyone who says Loud is either delusional, pressed, or just doing it for the lol's.

Katy obviously

Only Girl VS. California Gurls
What's My Name VS. Teenage Dream
S&M VS. Firework
California King Bed VS. E.T.
Man Down VS. Last Friday Night
Cheers VS. The One That Got Away

Teenage Dream

Only Girl (In the World) - California Gurls
What's My Name - Teenage Dream
S&M - Firework
California King Bed - E.T.
Man Down - Last Friday Night
Cheers (Drink to That) - The One That Got Away (this one's super close.)

TD

Only Girl (In the World) - California Gurls
What's My Name - Teenage Dream
S&M - Firework
California King Bed - E.T.
Man Down - Last Friday Night
Cheers (Drink to That) - The One That Got Away

Based on commercial success, Katy Perry.
Based on overall quality, Katy Perry.

Only Girl (In the World) - California Gurls
What's My Name - Teenage Dream
S&M - Firework
California King Bed - E.T.
Man Down - Last Friday Night
Cheers (Drink to That) - The One That Got Away

but overall album, Rihanna's still better.

Only Girl - California Gurls
What's My Name - Teenage Dream
S&M - Firework
California King Bed - E.T.
Man Down - Last Friday Night (tie)
Cheers - The One That Got Away

I gotta give it to Katy, slightly. Rih gets points for having a little more diversity though. I LOVE all of these songs btw.