If the following celebrities weren't famous yet and they joined the X factor, who would WIN

Beyonce
Rihanna
Britney (old)
Usher (old)
Justin Timberlake (old)
Chris Brown
Drake
Gaga
Justin Bieber
Jlo

*old*: their early days

RATINGS

5- Excellent dancing, Excellent voice, stage presence, charisma
4- great dancing, great voice, stage presence, charisma
3- great dancing, great voice
2- ok dancing and voice
1-weak but manageable
0- no talent

Usher


RATINGS: 4.4= 4

Beyonce


RATINGS: 4.8 = 5

Justin timberlake

Beyonce, Gaga, Chris, Justin and a young Usher are the only ones who could win a show like X Factor.

Out of those 5, Beyonce would have the best chance of winning; with Gaga at a close second.

Britney, Justin & Beyonce

Gaga would be Rachel

BEYONCE

I WAS JUST THINKING ABOUT THIS AN HOUR AGO.


The winner would be Britney in her prime.

VOCALLY

I'm thinking Beyoncé or Justin. Bieber would make it to the finals but only cos of girls that want his **** voting for him, not because of his voice.

Drake would be out on week one

It would be between Usher (dancing and singing), beyonce (dancing and singing), Justin timberlake(dancing and singing). Maybe Britney but she is only good in the dancing department. It also depends on the audience favorite

did you read American Idol, sis?

The X-Factor isn't only based on on vocals. It's stage presence, personality, etc. This ain't The Voice.

The only reason Brit might win is that well, she's a likable white girl tbh.

Bey and Usher posses all that.

THAT'S GREAT

Is it bad that I pictured Gaga's face on Rachel's fall gif lmao

Britney won a few singing competitions in the past. The girl can sing, she just doesn't use her voice for the type of songs that she sings. Britney is also an amazing dancer, so she got an advantage over other girls. + the likability factor where she destroys them all.

I think if they all were on X-factor, Gaga would tank, Rihanna would get eliminated short after Gaga, Beyonce would finish something like #4, and the finale would be between Britney & Justin.

edit: Justine Timberlake ofc. Justin Bieber something like #3 due to girl factor, but then again, JT is 10x cuter than Bieber, so Bieber doesn't really have a chance to get the girl vote. So I'd say week 1&2 eliminations: Drake, Gaga, week 3 Bieber, then Usher, Chris Brown, J Lo. and then rest ^

And I think gaga would be more like Misha B from x factor UK.

How could Britney win when the audition process is based on being a strong vocalist? She wouldn't even make it to the live show and yall know that, so why even bring her up?