Let's be real here, MELANIE ALWAYS GIVES THE BEST PERFORMANCES.

MELANIE. MUST. WIN. THAT PERFORMANCE...

What's so great about Chris?
Melanie better win this ****. Out of all contestants, Rene winning the 5M dollars will be so unfair and a ****ing waste.

Melanie slayed!! I wish she would have stepped away from the mic stand though.

And that is why Melanie ***** on the other two. Enough said.

Yassss Melanie Loved the staging!

American Idol has never been this bad. Even Lee and Crystal were better.

Good vocal. Not great. There were some moments that were a bit guttural and shrieky. Hated the song production. I hate the little run she does when she's supposed to hit the F5. Easily the best vocalist in the competition though.

Melanie sis!

Why do they need to even air tomorrow? Just give her the money and title.

UK winner Alexandras version ***** on this....and it has the Goddess Bey herself turning up..

That was noticeably better than the first time she sang it. It'll be kind of sad if she gets beat by that guy that can't sing a lick but really I don't care who wins. Hopefully next season is better.

This is awkward

Yes Melanie, already filling out stadiums of fans. When will the other two?

Alexandra/Beyonce XF performance is sooooooo much better.

These screaming mother****ers are startin to annoy me ...all of them are screaming like ****ing animals and i've had it ...

Such a good performance. I feel like she sang a little too similar to Beyonce though. She should have made it her own.

That man was stanning HARD for Melanie I might throw in some votes after that performance.


Let's keep this thread free of lies por favor.

Did that guy of the Church was having a breakdown?? WTF is wrong with him?

Melanie for the win though!

ya'll see the children crying for Melanie???

omg i missed ALANIS Morrissette, Avril, and R.Kelly???