Your Favorite American Idol - Page 3

Ro(he)y

B! A! B! Y! M! A! M! A!

This Goes Out To All My Baby Mamas. I Got Love For All My Baby Mamas!

Nick

Baby Mama is one of the best songs ever in the world. Ever.

Anthony K.

No doubt: Kelly Clarkson.

alex2020

kelly for sure

Virgin Whore

Kelly Clarkson by far! She is the one and original American Idol. Kelly has NEVER been in the bottom 3 before. Put Kelly and Carrie together and by far, Kelly can blow her away.

Arith

Fantasia.

smartah

Of the Winners...

Kelly > *gap* Carrie > *gap again* Ruben > Fantasia

Otherwise, the only ones I truly like not counting this season... Kelly and Diana. :P

----Mu-----

i just know Carrie and Kelly and both suck

Sir. Will

Kelly. durr

Mandisa, Fantasia

Mugshot

Quote:

Originally posted by Aerometis

Carrie and Diana. Kelly used to be but I am now so sick of her. She is so over-rated it's pathetic.

Exodus

hmm...

There are quite a few that I enjoyed. Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood are my favorite winners by far. As far as runners up, I like Clay Aiken for his voice and Diana Degarmo. As far as people who could have gone further, I believe Tamyra Grey, Kimberley Locke, Latoya London, and Vonzell were cheated out of finals positions. As far as people who could have gone further, Christina Christian (eliminated suspiciously when she had a sickness), Trenyce, and Lisa Tucker from this season. Josh Gracin isn't too bad either.