^ I agree with Will. All of Hilary Duff's movies suck, and I like most of Linday's movies. Freaky Friday did pretty well, and that's one of my favorite comedies.

Hilary's last movie made 17 million. That sucks. And it only opened with 6 million or so. That also sucks. With the production budget and the marketing budget they didn't even make their money back.

Hmmm...not true. 'Material Girls' and 'Food Fight' are coming out and both are total teeny bopper trash. Why so many lies? Lindsay on the other hand is doing high end indie movies with some of the best actors and directors in the industry.
Lindsay is doing great in movies. Every movie star has movies that do better then others but Hilary's last two films have absolutely bombed. She can't carry a movie anymore and has very little power at the box office. That's not the case for Lindsay. Hell even the Amanda bynes pic opened bigger then Hilary's last two attempts.
Like I said before, every actor has movies that are bigger then others but the point is that Herbie is a bonafide hit. That's why Lindsay makes 7.5 million per picture. Hilary can barely crack 17 million domestically LOL.

huh? lets see:

MOVIES (how the last 2 of both did in the US, in millions)
Lindsay: 65 - 85
Hilary: 16 - 10 (not counting CBTD2 cause she's just in a supporting, small role)

*Plus, Lindsay is starring in ROBERT ALTMAN's new film, and has just completed another movie called "Bobby" with Elijah Wood, Demi Moore and Anthony Hopkins. Hilary = FLOP FLOP FLOP FLOP in movies.

MUSIC
I don't know the actual facts but it's a universal truth that Lindsay doesn't sell half of what Hilary sells. so, Lindsay = FLOP FLOP FLOP in music.

Back to the thread, Wilmer Valderrama is an absolute asshole, no real man has the right to say such things about ex-girlfriends, the good thing about this is that people know that and now we will all know he's an ass hole .

Her last two movie bombed because one of them (TPM) came out at the absolute WRONG time. RYV really has no excuse except that it was a cheaper film than her other ones so it's not as bad looking as TPM. No Fool, I was talking about movies lined up for her to do. She has NONE. She finished Material Girls & Foodfight a LONG ass time ago.

Blah Blah, let's not make excuses for her failures. Herbie opened with MUCH tougher competition. It opened when all the massive summer blockbusters opened. Hilary's release date was much less competitve.
Outward Blonde, bitch.

AND Herbie was Disney's second higest grossing movie of the year. Muah ah ah, bitch.

Herbie was a DISNEY movie DUMBASS.... how would it fail? BTW - Outward Blonde has been on hold for such a long time she probably doesnt know if she's still going to do it

To take up for Lindsay..she is doing a movie called "A Prarie" with MERRYL STREEP and their is already oscar talk about that movie.


This guy is STUPID for telling personal business. But noone will care.

WTF is that even supposed to mean? 'The Perfect Man' is a Universal movie...how is supposed to fail!!!!!! Like seriously, you're making no sense. Disney has released flops before.
Disney was actually having a terrible year when Herbie was released but Lindsay saved the day
Excuses, excuses.

Okay, up until this, he was kinda cute. Maybe even a little hot. But now...that's just a jerk move.