Amy Winehouse... such amazing vocals... and she wrote her songs aswell... gaga tries to hard so it kinda doesn't seem sincere

Gaga

Winehouse >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>Gaga

Amy Winehouse.

Singing and songwriting - Amy
Seeking attention - Gaga

Amy.

Like somebody already said Gaga seems to try too hard, where as Amy naturally radiates talent.

And people saying gaga because she also directs music videos? Are we talking about TEOG video? As far as I know it was the only one she directed herself.

Dont be pathetic if u can. Watch A Very GaGa Thanksgiving which was entirely directed by her. Also wait for Marry the Night to come to town. You and I was mostly directed by GaGa herself.

I dont think its a good thing to compare the two. They are just different. Amy can never do GaGa and reversely. Amy can never pull a Born This Way performance at the Grammy while GaGa can never do a Back to Black.

I think some people are just too desperate since Amy is like a competition to GaGa while other girls are not. So its obvious to vote for Amy straight away.

Updated:

Amy 51
Gaga 20


p.s.
I can't at people saying gaga based on fashion "talents"

Amy.

Looks like this thread blew up. Let me read it

Amy Winehouse.

i really like some of gaga's songs
but i'll go with AMY

When someone dies their votes likely double, or triple. There was a study that was conducted I remember on the popularity and favorable opinion among deceased artists and how much it all increased after their deaths. Not a surprise.

Vin, knowing this, made this topic to somehow knock Gaga yet again. Very petty, but again, no surprise.
Not saying Amy can't get more votes cause she isn't more talented in people's eyes, but the difference wouldn't be as large.

I think it's Gaga, but it hurts to say so cause I love Amy!

Good lord ! *Screaming*

they are both very talented but i would say gaga because she is more well rounded.

Winehouse>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>Gaga