Lets get into this. Smash has Katharine McPhee (who is incredible), Megan Hilty (an excellent Broadyway actress), Brian D'Arcy James (another excellent Broadway actor, who was Shrek in Shrek the Musical) and the epic Angelica Houston.

The fact is, Glee is an auto-tuned pit. None of that cast besides Lea or Amber are actually talented live, and they edit everyone's voices in the studio to the MAX, plus its extremely cheesy, tired and just bad.

Smash has tons of great producers, Broadway composers are writing the ORIGINAL score, Speilberg is producing and the cast is excellent.

I hope it destroys Glee. Do you think it will?

Glee is already fading anyway....

Well I like Glee so...

I live for Katherine McPhee

"Glee" will continue to flop and this new show will be a flop from the beginning. America isn't here for scripted musicals on TV anymore.

Wait Katherine Mcphee? I'm watching.

no

Its not a scripted musical.

Its about people putting together a musical.

The general public won't know that; they'll assume it's a Glee rip-off.

Glee is atrocious. I don't like it.

This looks promising and exciting

Katharine McPhee

The sad thing is, Glee used to be great.

Yeah. The first half of the first season was SO GOOD.

Then it gradually went to ****; to the point where it's practically unwatchable.

TV version of Burlesque?

"Grace"

But, no. People are not here for broadway songs. Glee tried to push Broadway starting season 3 and they stared to flop. Now they realized the reason for flopping and trying to get it back on track with better music.

Burlesque is trash compared to what this could be.

Maybe, its on NBC though...which I am worry about. If it were on like HBO or AMC it would have a higher chance.

But Katharine McPhee

i'm tired of karok shows

Uh, no. "Glee" is flopping because the second season was horrendous. You can't destroy everything that was once good about your show and expect fans to stick around. I give it one more season—tops.