hmmm, I'm pretty sure it was lipped:-\

what proof this those persons give you that she wasn't lipping?

I said it...she was singing in her live voice and also because u can hear the breathing(which matched her voice).When u sing a POWERFUL song u have to breathe..and all her actions matched her breathing(no one is that good of a lipper.)

And her live voice...her voice is more deeper and soul-like live but when she records it is more poppish.

What proof do u have that shows that she lipped it, do u think its impossible for someone to sing it live?

I know

-Beyonce was more of annoying .

-DC sounded like they have been rehearsing for months ,even the way they walked at the begining. LFR

-I didn't feel comfortable in whitney's .

-Mariah was the best among them , She did give a feeling to that performance and she did every part more than perfect . (btw , the whispers were the best parts).

I loved how they introduced her as the biggest selling female artist in HISTORY!

Well, Jojo did it better than DC & Beyonce . This girl can SING!
http://www.youtube.com/?v=2CH88Xl1Otw

Whitney. Hands down.

Mariah's version was the worst.

They just have that connection and chemistry.....

Whitney, DC then B........never heard Mariah's.