Oh, but the editing of You and I is great, tbqh.

Then again, I'm not an editing expert like most Gaga fans, so IDRK.

Caliber as in quality?

I think the song is AMAZING, but Judas, Born This Way, TEOG > Bad Romance.

I thought about that word choice after I posted. Caliber as in how much of a game changer it could be.

I would say Judas/TEOG are equal to Bad Romance, and that Born This Way isn't quite as good as BR.

Oh, and on the editing, it's pretty good. There's one slip up when she's doing the choreo in the bar; the color completely changes, lol.

Judas is a perfect song and a perfect video. You all will deal. Everyone went mad when that demo leaked. It raised the bar, just like Bad Romance did. The only thing that went wrong is that for her standards its a flop because it leaked and was rush-released to iTunes with only 3 days of sales. Stop hating on Judas. It's her best song.

Judas is a masterpiece and one of the best things to come out this era.

I think the story line is ****ing backwards or some ****.

I also think the video was supposed to be creepy in a sense and the quick flashes reminded me of a horror story.

I think a professional does edit it. When Gaga says "I'm editing", she mostly likely means, "I'm with someone editing it." xD

Yes, def. agree.

I'm bias when it comes to BTW 'cause I love Rico.

I was going to mention the slip up during the barn. I also wonder if the part where the camera slides up is intentional or not...

Ugh, I hate that ****ing leak. It could have been another #1 debut with a full ****ing week. UGH@jfhsdjkdfhsdkjh

Judas operates completely below the bar, which was set by Bad Romance.

I love Judas. Its one of my favourite videos. The concept with the bikie gang is amazing and im glad it wasnt too controversial.

No Judas hate over here.

It's the 3rd of any Gaga song of mine to get over 1k plays (BR, Alejandro being the other 2).


I personally loved the video.

I don't think it raised any bars though unless you count pissing more people off than ever raising the bar.

Naw. The video was amazing. She looked good, it was good and the original plot was . Judas making out with Jesus. I wonder how that would have looked. Anyways, the video was good only the audio editing a bit rough on the times it completely was no sound when the waves scene happened. It's a msaterpiece and you will deal!

Exactly! Judas is so addictive you could watch and hear it 10 times and still be amazed wanting more. That's how it's perfect: Hence approx 110 mil views, the most of this era.

I agree with the Judas video being average, but the water scene slays video catalogs.

What's everyone's favorite part of Judas, the song?


For me, I can't live without the chorus.

I just get so emotional when I hear it.

I remember when it was released, I couldnt stop watching it

I love the dance scenes and where she does the heart sign. Ch'Yeah.

I looove the end part, at about 3.38

Judas had a amazing video.
The only two things that I didn't like was the moment when she went into the bar (too much going on) and the fact that just before the water scene you can already hear the next sentence starting.