It's her best video this era, but that isn't saying much. It doesn't horrify me like BTW, it doesn't leave me scratching my head like Judas and it doesn't bore me to tears like EOG. But it's still far from a great video, and it's still very much beneath the caliber of Paparazzi and Bad Romance.
I enjoyed all her videos pre-BTW, but ever since this era started, it's been bad decision after bad decision in regards to videos and single choices.
Gaga's videos always get progressively better, with TEOG being a minor flaw in that system. Paparazzi > LoveGame > Poker Face > Just Dance. We're ignoring Eh Eh, just like we'll ignore TEOG
So I really think You and I, an amazing video, is not even the best to come. In the meantime, I hope You and I continues to get great recognition
