Which do you prefer out of the 2?

B'Day is one of the best pop albums of the last decade.

4

Same here. it was my favorite until 4

Deja Vu vs. 1+1
Get Me Bodied vs. I Care
Suga Mama vs. I Miss You
Upgrade U vs. Best Thing I Never Had
Ring the Alarm vs. Party
Kitty Kat vs. Rather Die Young
Freakum Dress vs. Start Over
Green Light vs. Love On Top
Irreplaceable vs. Countdown
Resentment vs. End of Time
Lost Yo Mind vs. I Was Here
Creole vs. Run the World (Girls)

I chose my 2 favorite bonus tracks as track 11 and 12.

Anyway, the winner is 4, 7 to 5. B'Day is a very close second, though. They are both amazing records.

Bday is one of the bests albums I listened my inteir life so it gots my vote.

Deja Vu vs. 1+1
Get Me Bodied vs. I Care
Suga Mama vs. I Miss You
Upgrade U vs. Best Thing I Never Had
Ring the Alarm vs. Party
Kitty Kat vs. Rather Die Young
Freakum Dress vs. Start Over
Green Light vs. Love On Top
Irreplaceable vs. Countdown
Resentment vs. End of Time
Lost Yo Mind vs. I Was Here
Creole vs. Run the World (Girls)

B'Day

Damn, I meant to vote for B'Day.

And @ somebody calling it a Pop album.

LOVE LOVE LOVE 4 and B'Day

It depends. If I wanna shake my ***** to some crazy ass dance beats and get my freak on, B'Day is for me

And if I feel like taking a break from it all and listen to R&B/Soul infused records...4 is the way to go

This is too hard.

I wanna say that their equal, but 4 has that slight edge so I voted for it.

Both are masterpieces for different reasons.

1) Bday is a flawless album, so it wins
2) This practice of comparing albums track by track this way is ridiculous. Just because 2 songs are track 1 doesn't mean they are the ones who should be compared

Quatre Vier Fjórir Neljä Quattuor

Deja Vu vs. 1+1
Get Me Bodied vs. I Care
Suga Mama vs. I Miss You
Upgrade U vs. Best Thing I Never Had
Ring the Alarm vs. Party
Kitty Kat vs. Rather Die Young
Freakum Dress vs. Start Over
Green Light vs. Love On Top
Irreplaceable vs. Countdown
Resentment vs. End of Time
Lost Yo Mind vs. I Was Here
Creole vs. Run the World (Girls)

4 - 8
B'Day - 2
Tie - 2

4 won easely.