Anyone who says or said that The Edge of Glory is a bad song or did not deserve to be a single deserves to be shot.
The Edge of Glory is an absolutely amazing song and like other GaGa songs, the timing was entirely wrong. I have a feeling The Edge of Glory is the "chart performing" Bad Romance from this album (Being blocked by other songs that are a part of the current radio fad).
Anyhow, You and I isn't a bad song, but that's not what the fans or the public really wants. They want Fame GaGa and they can't have it. Therefore, she needs to give them the best substitute and that's the DANCE songs from Born This Way; i.e. Marry The Night, Scheisse, Americano, Heavy Metal Lover, etc,..
Interscope needs to get the timing right this time or it'll be another disaster. Hopefully by doing the video before announcing the single will help them so that whenever they need the buzz from the video, they can simply release it instead of trying to rush the product. Time and time again it has been proven that more than anything the problem with GaGa's singles are not the singles itself, but the organization behind them. The timing is always wrong and the videos and performances aren't handled correctly. This is ultimately due to as Nicole and other people preach, GaGa's free reign as it were and the Haus of GaGa.
They'll get it right eventually.
