If we're talking about the album versions, then Y&I, by far. The choice gets a bit harder if comparing the live versions, I might have to go with Speechless on that count.

I love both songs!, but my vote is for Yoü and I

Speechless.

You & I

PREACH SIS

i really love both.. but im going with "Speechless" it means so much to me

Studio: Yoü and I
Unplugged: Speechless

Both are boring as hell but Speechless is shorter and more tolerable than YAI

Studio version: You and I
Live: Speechless

You and I

HEEEEEEEEEEELLL NOOOOOOOO!!

You and i studio version REALLY SUCKS

Speechless

.

This one destroys Speechless imo.

I agree with this one.

Speechless

The Yoü and I studio version SLAYS the live version. I had to turn off the live version the other day because of how flat she was. The new lyrics make the song for me.