You and I = Speechless for me but I voted You and I.

Don't even try it.

Speechless > every other song she's ever done.

There's something, something about You & I that causes me to skip it most of the time. I like the song and all but... idk.

So Speechless it is.

You and I. As for the other one, its messy production killed the song. Its live version slays though.

Speechless >>>>

Yoü and I is one of her worst songs ever.

I dislike both a lot but I'll go with Speechless.

You and I

When she sing Speechless live, she is somehow more emotional than usual. I love emotional Gaga.

When she sing You and I live, she only shout "I rather die, without you and I I I !!!!" That's kinda boring imo. The only part i love is the part she sing "my daddy and Nebraska and Jesus Christ"

Speechless

You and I.
Speechless imo is overproduced

I really like both, but I voted for You and I. Probably because it's the newer one.

Yoü And I.

Frog & I.

Speechless

You & I is just horrible. I can never listen to it in full...it's way too long

On the other hand...Speechless is the 3rd best song on TFM, after Dance In The Dark and Telephone. It's SO good, and I wished she would have released it, even if it would flop

Speechless.. Y&I is kinda crappy.

Speechless

Yoü And I>>>>

Speechless is overproduced