Is it too long? I could set it up in a shorter format, but I kind of like how long it takes tbh. It seems more involved, & I get more of a variety of people giving answers, so therefore the results would maybe more accuratley represent what ATRL actually thinks of the songs.

Thoughts? Vote.

I like it this way. However, you can do this kind of method:

A vs B. A wins. Then, A vs C. C wins. Then, C vs D. This would be shorter.

Though, the method you're doing is more specific / accurate.

I like how specific the current method is.

By the way, GaGa's Versus Game is by far the most popular one. It always gets the most replies.

+1

LOve it!!

Keep going and finish up the games you have. You can reassess after these are done, but I personally like it. It won't work for every album, but big, popular ones with a lot of interest like those you chose? Definitely.

I like this

I agree.

I think I'm going to do an experimental round (aka the shorter version) with BEP's The Beginning or ADELE's 21 & see how it goes after the three current games are finished.