No. Just no.

i swear i would single handedly derail this thread to death if i dont have so many points. this is a ****ing lie

i'll make my exit for the time being.

its good, but it does not have the gaga factor. To be honest, i prefer her music videos simple.

It's not a bad video. It's the WORST video of the year. There's no concept and no storyline even if her little monsters try to invent something to justify its simpliness. You can even see the shadow of the camera in some scenes, and that is a huge and unforgivable cinamatographic mistake!!
It's a dissapointment. She needs to work with profesional directors again and stop that amateur, cheap way to make her videos. What's next? A video of her in pijamas filmed at home with her webcam where she only lipsincs... I bet her fans would say something like "Ohh I love this video, it was meant to be like this, she dedicated it to us, her fans..." Bitch please...

HarrySapphire
Banned



anyway, i disliked this video very much, but as a stan, im glad she receives positive reviews from critics. she best not ****ing around with MTN and Hai'rs video, tho

http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/166...of-glory.jhtml

NOW YOU CAN TAKE A SEAT CAUSE YOU DONT KNOW **** ABOUT MAKING A VIDEO AND THE EDGE OF GLORY VIDEO IS >>>>>>>>>>>> AND YOU WILL DEAL !!!

OMG. Who's that guy?

On Topic: Gaga still had the power to "shock" everyone even the critics with one of her frailest videos to date. She doesn't disappoint, at the very least, to maintain that factor.

i looooooved the song, but video is

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAH Poor Bitch

^^^ This. Well at least most of it. I think it's far from being her worst video (that dubious distinction belongs to BTW, IMO), but it definitely doesn't rank as one of her best, either. There's quite a difference between being simple and boring, and unfortunately this video is solely the latter. It really does look like it was shot at the last minute on some used studio lot. It doesn't have any feeling for me. So far I haven't been impressed with ANY of Gaga's videos this era. The last video of hers that I've enjoyed was "Alejandro".

I really think this is just a placebo effect. Gaga's been so OTT with her videos that the moment she stopped doing it everyone was so astonished and amazed that they think it's the best thing she's ever put out.

Are the labels paying the critics ? Even the stans are saying this is Gaga's worst video then who in God names are the haters ? I love gaga and I'm really disappointed by the video. lol something is fishy with the critics these days.

TEOG wasnt as good as Judas, but not BAD.

I agree. It wasn't bad at all. It feels wrong calling it the worst gaga video cause gaga doesn't have bad videos. This was simply just a OKAY video. When a artist released something epic every single time and then suddenly just releases something in terms of TEOG, then yes it can be a bit disappointing and because of that, it will be called the worst.

the video ****ing sucks and that is the tea.
it's a ****ing mess, just like this whole era.

Who the **** cares?
The bitch makes a normal video and the world goes crazy.
I haven't even seen the last one.

·%FREWWEADsfaeg3432rf


I don't understand her, nor her monsters, nor the critics, and obviously the "hidden" concept of the video. A whole round mess.

The video sucks. Don't care what the critics say.