Originally posted by RobynYoBank

We'll see, ha. The problem is that the remix of E.T. was used as the primary when sent to radio INITIALLY. It built it's entire airplay and fanbase off of the remix. In addition, when people download, they probably aren't even sure which one is the radio one, hence why E.T. and E.T. feat. Kanye are both doing well.

In the case of S&M, the original song is the primary version that has built a foundation on radios. The Britney remix isn't going to do much. I'd say you're going to get the most help from the Britney fanbase, because her part certainly doesn't add anything to the song. Rihanna's original sounds better on the radio than this remix. With E.T., though Kanye's parts weren't very good, he added a sort of universal appeal to the song, something Britney doesn't.

Originally posted by Cahleb

THIS IS AWFUL!!!!!

Britney sounds like that tall girl from that show Recess.

Originally posted by RobynYoBank

Definitely not better than the Video Phone remix in terms of their relative impact on the song. I think the original S&M is better than this remix. The Video Phone remix is MUCH better than the original. The original is so boring and flat throughout. Gaga sort of provided a much-needed variation in the sound of the song. Not talking about the video.

Originally posted by Deemy

Britney's horny accent

Originally posted by heteroflexible

i think i love you tew gorl

Originally posted by Toastyrokr

I thought the original was much better actually...I thought Gaga could've made it fire but it was boring to me idk...and we can't really judge the ACTUAL impact yet. S&M's remix has been out for less than 12 hours. We'll have to wait until the #'s are in to see the true impact. But Video Phone's weren't sufficient at all

Originally posted by RobynYoBank

I meant impact on the sound of the song moreso than the commercial impact. I can't listen to Bey's album version of Video Phone...so, so boring and flat. But I enjoy the remix on occasion.

Originally posted by RudeBoy

Hopefully will get more of these two, just like Beyonce & GaGa. This is my dream collaboration happening! Can't believe it's happening!

Originally posted by BabeMonster

Originally posted by BabeMonster

Originally posted by RobynYoBank

Originally posted by RobynYoBank

Originally posted by RobynYoBank

I'm pretty sure E.T. will come close to S&M in airplay this week. Not only that, but E.T.'s remixed version is getting almost twice the sales of S&M, not to mention there is the original version still charting high.

Originally posted by RobynYoBank

I would say it has a chance to be #1, but definitely not a huge chance. E.T. is an absolute monster at the moment and chasing down Rihanna's airplay fast as hell.

Originally posted by RobynYoBank

We'll see, ha. The problem is that the remix of E.T. was used as the primary when sent to radio INITIALLY. It built it's entire airplay and fanbase off of the remix. In addition, when people download, they probably aren't even sure which one is the radio one, hence why E.T. and E.T. feat. Kanye are both doing well.

In the case of S&M, the original song is the primary version that has built a foundation on radios. The Britney remix isn't going to do much. I'd say you're going to get the most help from the Britney fanbase, because her part certainly doesn't add anything to the song. Rihanna's original sounds better on the radio than this remix. With E.T., though Kanye's parts weren't very good, he added a sort of universal appeal to the song, something Britney doesn't.

Originally posted by RobynYoBank

Definitely not better than the Video Phone remix in terms of their relative impact on the song. I think the original S&M is better than this remix. The Video Phone remix is MUCH better than the original. The original is so boring and flat throughout. Gaga sort of provided a much-needed variation in the sound of the song. Not talking about the video.

Originally posted by RobynYoBank

I meant impact on the sound of the song moreso than the commercial impact. I can't listen to Bey's album version of Video Phone...so, so boring and flat. But I enjoy the remix on occasion.

Originally posted by BabeMonster