It's hilarious and quite surprising, from her.

They paid for that song, and they got nothing. I would be mad too.

didn't expect her do lie to her fans like that

AP 2 weeks ago

Yeah I know...that's what I wrote above.

But look at my thread and yours. See the difference.

$50 for a fan club is too much.

For that I'd expect a whole bunch of exclusive merchandise and a new song.

i find this quite convincing, but i doubt she'd do it.

Ha! @ her snatching that money and running.

ok guys....i LOVE SHAKIRA since i was 4 years old..
i own all her cds, this woman is amazing... but
we dont know her personality, who she really is...
all i know is: i have a friend back in colombia, a 16 y/old girl whose aunt or uncle (dont remember) is married to shakira's sibling...and she says that everyone in the family know shakira is an odious woman... she seems sweet and devoted, but nah... she is arrogant and a bitch... :O (and the thing is, my friend is also a shaki stan O.o)
i dont know what to believe anymore
still...love this woman!

Shakira just wanted to teach these people a lesson that you should not waste $50 on something like an official fan club. I'd say that lesson is worth $50.

Meanwhile Shakira to her most devoted fans...

I'm seeing her LIVE in concert with Pitbull next Wednesday!!!

i don't believe this .

You should read this...!

http://community.shakira.com/topic/6...C-RECORDS.html

ok guys....i LOVE SHAKIRA since i was 4 years old..
i own all her cds, this woman is amazing... but
we dont know her personality, who she really is...
all i know is: i have a friend back in colombia, a 16 y/old girl whose aunt or uncle (dont remember) is married to shakira's sibling...and she says that everyone in the family know shakira is an odious woman... she seems sweet and devoted, but nah... she is arrogant and a bitch... :O (and the thing is, my friend is also a shaki stan O.o)
i dont know what to believe anymore
still...love this woman!

Chemist better come and explain this to us.

The part about the charity is awful, like, really no need to have that in their, your asking people not to donate to charity :S wtf!