Both S&M and E.T. are in the U.S. iTunes top 5 and are on the cusp of becoming huge smashes. Of these, what will smash harder in the US?

Take into account peak, total sales, radio play, and impact.



VS.

E.T > S&M.

E.T. will smash harder than S&M

Peak : E.T.
Sales : E.T.
Radio Airplay : S&M

I prefer E.T.,Katy's best song.

I think theyll both peak around the same position(top 3 or 4) but I went with E.T.

Katy's singles have been consistently outdoing Rih's for years now, and I don't think the trend is going to change.

In the US : E.T

But WW : S&M

E.T. is Katy's finest song she ever did, vocal, production and lyrics-wise. Now let's see how the video turns out, which should premiere next week?

Too early to say. ET is doing amazing but it almost got 1st single treatment.

E.T because she is treating it like a brand new song by adding Kanye to it. it would have an edge in downloads because this version is not on the original Teenage dream but I dont necessarily mind.

US: E.T
WW: S&M

It'll be even. They'll both hit #1. End of.

E.T. >>>>>>>>>>>>>> S&M

You honestly think Kanye would hold the single back from having success? I mean, almost IMMEDIATELY after the remix with Kanye was added to ITunes it was surged into the top 10, as opposed to the original which was floundering in the top 1000 for months.

E.T. is Katy's best song, but the remix sucks. It'll prolly still do well since it's getting special treatment.

I vote for E.T. such a masterpiece *_*

ET since they're going all out with it.

On The Floor.

But anyway, so many people thought E.T. would flop. I'm sick of Katy but I love that song.