Im sorry but Halo was intended for Leona Lewis..... and its supposed written in 3 hours in tedder's studio....

And hearing the Demo of Halo and Beyonce's I DONT HEAR ANY NEW LYRICS..... actually in Beyonce's song there is one less verse, than in the original demo....

and hering G4L demo I dont hear any new lyrics either.... but I hear that the last minute is totally different... and Rihanna's song ends with the 'I lick the gun when Im done coz I know that revenge is sweet'..... that's not in the original demo

ok? and? what does leona have to do with this? nothing!

you obviously don't know what constitutes as songwriting. it's not just about lyrics. Beyonce and her co-writers have been very clear on what she mainly contributes to songwriting which is vocal production, vocal arrangement, etc. the drums are different and so is the vocal arrangement.

and you know if beyonce would have just ended one of her songs with a line already sung earlier in the song then you would be bitcing about that. don't play
when will you people learn?

Re-arranging and instrumentation is part of songwriting whether you like it or not. And Tedder did not co-write Halo WITH her. He sent her a demo, and left it for her to record. He THEN offered it to Leona Lewis because Beyonce taking a long time to record it so he wasn't sure if she was going to use it, he said so himself.

and in regards to your previous post, she DID edit the dvd. She chose exactly what scenes she wanted etc. You can tell because it took damn near a whole year. Whereas The Beyonce Experience and I am Yours took only a couple of months because she had another director to it for her.

yes. what these girls don't get is that we aren't just saying this. it's literally a fact.

Right. I swear people see the songwriters on a song an automatically assume all of them had a role in the lyrics. Often not how it works.

Im sorry but in my country that is called PRODUCTION. Songwritting = WRITING LYRICS.

Re-arrange = Re-arrange
Instrumentation = Instrumentation

and Im sure she doesnt arrange any song... She may say she likes this better than that, but she does not know how to arrange anything... she is no sound engineer.... dont be delusional.

as well as she doesnt know how to edit a video.

Choosing what part of the song goes and what doesnt = CREATIVE PRODUCTION
Choosing what performance goes in the DVD and what doesnt = CREATIVE PRODUCTION/DIRECTION

WRITING LYRICS = SONGWRITING

LOL. NO.

Lyricist = writing lyrics
Songwriting = lyrics AND composition/production

and what on earth do you mean "in your country"??? songwriting is the same wherever you go

it doesn't matter what you say. It's a fact of life and you will have to deal with it.


you obviously just are going to beleive whatever you want to beleive.

you really don't know what you're talking about. Since when is ARRANGING sound engineering? They are two entirely different things.

HIDE YO CREDITS!!!

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&d...Q&ved=0CBMQkAE

sorry to burst your bubble zzmyth

OK, maybe my problem is that I always associated songwriter = lyricist

Its a matter of language. My english is yet to be perfect. You are right with the songwriting thing.

So what I said is not valid, coz I was saying that I didnt believe that beyonce WROTE THE LYRICS of her songs.

That's what I meant.

i can take back my words when I have to

I like it, Bey can just drop th enew single now, the haters are soooo ready! I can't believe they are still trying it.


Contribute the least to the song, there's nowhere where it says didn't contribute at ALL! Plus these other people were in the writing credits. It was funny the 1st time, but today your shade just fell flat.

Please some fans complained it was all over the place, a little messy and it was definitely the work of a person that debuts in editing. But you know it better than me considering you watched it! Go back spamming the charts threads, your whole post doesn't make any sense.

How many singers have a HUGE voice(your words) and dance amanzingly? Overrated yeah, you definately know everything about that.....

Thakns for watching the DVD though, you're such a stan! I mean I'm a fan and I haven't even watched it yet!
So much free promotion. Keep going! I think I'm slowly turning into a stan, and all of that thanks to these bitter bloggers.

GURL! BYE!

the prophet, huh

*walks away*

God this Beyonce needs a new nickname...
http://atrl.net/?p=4809038

blog articles threads

"I Am... A Liar"