Quote:
Originally posted by Kworb
As a society we need to get over this concept that dissing old boybands like the Beatles invalidates your overall artistic taste. Objectively, the Beatles were a poor band, poor singing, poor musicianship, but decent songwriting skills. It is no crime to admit this. When performed by others, some of their songs come alive. But when performed by themselves their stuff is no better than any lame garage band. Their music is not special. You don't have to pretend that it is. Everyone needs to stop pretending.
|
At all of that being linked together.
Please. Cool for you that you don't like their music but don't act like it's a general fact because IT IS NOT!!!
I do love their music and I don't understand how somebody can invalidate the amazing work they put out like you just did. So you're telling me that the millions people that bought their albums did because of pretending?
And that poor musicianship part? Really? listen to the arrangements in "Let it be" more notable during the bridge, and come back and talk about poor musicianship. The same goes with "Come together", the work Lennon did on that one is fabulous, and the simplicity of Help is transcending.
Don't get me wrong I have any problem with you not liking the Beatles, but don't make your case a normality.
Oh and I've never ever heard a cover of "Let it be" that comes close to the Paul Mc Cartney's version. They never claimed to be vocal beasts, that wasn't their goal, they wanted to make magic MUSIC with powerful lyrics that conduct real emotions and they totally succeed at it.
And I'm not even a Beatles's fan, actually I find them
sighly overrated.
Quote:
Originally posted by Kworb
It was no different than 'N Sync selling 2.4 million in one week.
|

Ok forget about my comment, I shouldn't have bothered.
