I guess she can be a good judge

I love it how they don't even mention that Mariah Eclipses Cheryl when it comes to talent and musical knowledge . AND IT'S A TALENT SHOW.

No, it's about accents and who is the bigger celebrity

And the ignorance of some, talking how that girl is better than Mimi? C'mon now which world are we living in?
I really think if Cheryl became the judge, she wil be overcriticized everytime because of her lack in talent department. How are you going to judge talent, if you don't have too much of it? Americans won't have it.
Plus that news is false anyway. I doubt Mimi will want to be a judge, it's like declaring to the world "my career is over".

they can put subtitles on while she's speaking.

plus you're all acting way too hard like cheryl is speaking gobbledegook. She speaks english for christ's sake. I can understand her and please we never watch harry potter for the accents.

mariah was pretty worried with david cook singing "always be my baby" his own way.

the ignorance.

what does that have to do with anything I said?

mariah would be epic

I love Mimi and don't care about Cole, she's a nobody everywhere but in UK. Slap her Mimi, rob her job!

I don't see how Mimi being a 'Diva' would stop people from tuning it. It would more than likely make people want to see it Imagine the entertainment of her and Simon together ona judging panel Plus, it's not like she wouldn't be professional, she know's exactly what she is talking about and will have amazing advice and constructive critisism.

If by any chance Mariah's gonna do The X Factor US, she needs to rekindle the inner Bianca within. That aletr-ego was the ****.

OMG. This would be amazing, if it were true. I can already imagine all the gifs that Mimi will provide.

Cheryl doesn't have the "X" factor, needed to be a successful judge in the U.S. Mariah would be perfect for this role.

Lol, X Factor vs. American Idol, Mariah Carey vs. J-Lo.

Mariah will be another Paula... sugarcoating what sounds good or bad. She said a few years ago that she couldn't hurt people's feelings if they sounded bad, and she even referenced Paula.

Bianca.

Mariah is undeniably more talented, shes more suited.

Yesss! The gifs would be priceless.

Mariah would win. Mariah has an entertaining personality.

who the **** is cheryl cole. just put the Queen in her place

This isn't happening

Cheryl has said in interviews this week she has spoke about it numorous times with Simon and she would definitely do it and if you have been reading interviews with Simon this week, he's said Cheryl is his best friend and when he's with her he forgets about everyone else :heart:

If she wants to do it, she will be doing it
Just watching the XF you can see Simon eats out of Cheryl's hand and Cheryl laps up every word he says.

I would love them BOTH to do it though :heart:
Oh, imagine the reported fueds there would be

Yes. This would be amazing. Mariah >>>>>>>> Cheryl