So why would they play it now?
Oh yeah, cause it completely sucks in comparison to all Mariah christmas songs.
Get outta here. Mariah is the queen of christmas.

They would play it now because they weren't aware of its greatness then.
Gaga is the new queen of Christmas.

Gaga is the queen of christmas when she has arguably the biggest selling christmas album of all time.

Yet she has no Christmas album to compare to Mariah's...

Last I knew, the song was not even in the top 300 on iTunes.

I'm going to save my enthusiasm for when it makes a dent in the Hot 100.

this song is hilarious lol. I remeber listening this in 2008 going like wtf is this... lol

Then how can she be the new queen of Christmas?
Halloween? Maybe.

As much as I like Lady Gaga, some people should stop trying to make her kind of Miss Best in Everything.

I can hardly think of anyone from current pop music who is further away from christmas music wheras Mariah is already an established christmas singer.

But I think the user who brought it up wasnt really serious. Well, I hope.

This girl would never replace Mariah Carey! not in Christmas not in anything.

Plus, "Christmas Tree" is being released as a single in some countries this year.