Taylor has a lot of tween fans. This movie may lose her that particular fan base.
And yeah, Taylor isn't right for that role.

I disagree with you guys

taylor made Valentines Day a funny movie
i like the idea
btw, Lindsay is better actress

Why does almost every singer think they can be an actress?

Lindsay's life is a mess but she can act and well Taylor just not!

I think I would perfer Lindsay. =/

I can see her in this movie but not Taylor.

This.

Oh damn please don't

Nooo!

Never Taylor. Lindsay >>>>>

Taylor Let it be!

Taylor is one of the worst actresses ever. I literally cringed several times during Valentine's Day because her scenes were so embarrassing to watch.