Who do you think is the better black American Idol alumn from Season 3?
The idol winning, well known recording artist, or the oscar/grammy winning finalist?

Jennifer Hudson

Fantasia's recent work has been underwhelming and though she is great as well, I prefer Jennifer.

Her life is a mess though, Hudson is more likeable.

Hudson easily.

Definitely Fanny

Hudson

If This Isn't Love was my jam last year

I could never choose between them because I love them both so much. But Fantasia does have 3 full albums that I can play from beginning to end. I love Jennifers album as well and I cant wait for more.

I'm not a fan of their music so I'll try to weigh it on I Believe vs. If This Isn't Love.


I Believe wins.

I'd say Jennifer.

Jennifer Hudson by far

J-Hud

All around amazing.

Jennifer Hudson by far

LaToya London