Never change army, never change

Never change, Army (and I'm not even a Beyoncé stan) . We're comparing 2 mainstream female artists here, not indie artists.

That's the only thing the GP cares about + I still hear Womanizer in clubs.

Circus obviously.. She had documentaries, it was her first comeback since Blackout era, it spawned several WW hit singles, not too mention a huge no.1 which is still heard today in clubs and on the radio.. her life was on complete lockdown due to ha impact.. she literally couldnt go ANYWHERE without being mobbed.

Lemonade is breaking records left and right, topping 2016's touring gross, album sales, single sales, and acclaim lists, winning more awards and nominations than any other album, yet it's still somehow not enough to beat Circus?

Apparently Circus had impressive singles. How do its sales compare to other albums of 2008/2009? Was it annihilating IASF, TF/M, Fearless?

Circus is still remembered lemonade will be forgotten in a few years like 4 and IAMSF

Thank you for exemplifying ATRL's delusional mindset when it comes to Britney.


Unfortunately for you, the topic you chose is one that can be easily argued with statistics.


All Britney songs in the top 1500 iTunes:

598 Britney Spears Slumber Party (feat. Tinashe)
1233Britney Spears My Only Wish (This Year)

I dont think either are on Circus.


All Beyonce songs in the top 1500 iTunes:

93 Beyoncé Sorry
120 Beyoncé Formation
127 Beyoncé Hold Up
167 Beyoncé All Night
411 Beyoncé 6 Inch (feat. The Weeknd)
550 Beyoncé Pray You Catch Me
574 Beyoncé Halo
641 Beyoncé Daddy Lessons
682 Beyoncé Freedom (feat. Kendrick Lamar)
788 Beyoncé Partition
798 Beyoncé Don't Hurt Yourself (feat. Jack White)
818 Beyoncé Love Drought
836 Beyoncé Sandcastles
896 Beyoncé If I Were a Boy
976 Beyoncé Love On Top
1360Beyoncé Drunk in Love (feat. Jay Z)

I see plenty from IASF/4, and Lemonade seems to holding up fine (compared to Glory songs).

Fun fact: Halo, Single Ladies, Run The World and Love On Top all EACH got more recurrent streams within the last year than Womanizer and Circus got in the same time period, combined.

They each got more recurrent streams than the whole damn album.

Oh well, the Hive can try it but Circus is winning the poll and looks like it's the bigger era

Circus >

Looks like Circus was by far the bigger era. The Hive is the most delusional fanbase, how can they even think Lemonade was bigger than Circus
I hope it's just to defend their fave cause Lemonade looks like a flop next to Circus.

TEA!

And whoa @ the LOTB slayage Who else but Rihanna?

ICONIC

And trying it, they are Oh well

Circus was a bigger era than Lemonade but as albums Lemonade is a better quality album than any Britney album and Lemonade will be more remembered in the long-term. Lemonade is a classic album, Circus isn't even a solid pop album and is actually one of Britney's worst imo.

The Hive confusing Beyonce being bigger during Lemonade than Britney during Circus with Lemonade being bigger than Circus. Britney was bigger during ST than she was during BOMT, but that does not mean Britney was the bigger era.

Circus was bigger than Lemonade.


U.S. Billboard Hot 100 Artists - 2009

#7 Britney Spears

U.S. Billboard 200 Artists - 2009

#6 Britney Spears



U.S. Billboard Hot 100 Artists - 2016

#27 Beyonce

U.S. Billboard 200 Artists - 2016

#4 Beyonce

Social 50 and Touring wasn't included back then, so the only comparable ones are the Hot 100 and Billboard 200

Circus spawned better stats. Lemonade was truly hitless.

Oh well, indeed

Is Britney's career in such a tragic state that this poll is you have left to feel good as a stan?

Sis, I'm just comparing the Queen B's sixth studio albums
No need to be sour.