Her pure album sales and digital track sales benefited hugely as a result of the no streaming. We can't say whether it hurt her or not.
We just had a thread discussing how 60% of Apple music users hasn't used iTunes in a year. I'm sure Spotify numbers are even higher. Beyoncé is still selling to her strong fanbase (the same fanbase that bought her "flop" yet platinum 4 album)
Seriously though, they both had a great year, but it's a giggle and a half when you see people running around trying SO hard to discredit the Lemonade era only to end up getting sat right back on down again and again.
Kinda funny
Poor ATRL.