Poll: Does Madonna have the most classics? - Page 4

Wildcat

Yes.

Quote:

Originally posted by T.O.A.D.S.

Madonna's Classics

Holiday
Lucky Star
Borderline
Crazy For You
Like A Virgin
Material Girl
Into The Groove
Papa Don't Preach
La Isla Bonita
Who's That Girl
Vogue
Frozen
Ray of Light
Music
Hung Up
4 Minutes

Dress You Up
Live To Tell
Open Your Heart
Like A Prayer
Express Yourself
Justify My Love
Secret
Take A Bow
Dont' Cry For Me Argentina

Queen Of Music, hihi

.

idkher

Quote:

Originally posted by Entity

Madonna: Vogue, Like A Virgin, Like A Prayer

Whitney: IWALY and I Have Nothing

Mariah: No true classics in the same caliber as IWALY, Like A Virgin, Vogue, etc. The closest is probably Hero. But even that is stretching it. Many hits but no cigar.

Celine: [Insert Mariah's situation here]

Whitney and Madonna are close, but I give Madonna the edge simply for the fact that her legacy isn't highly concentrated on one era/album.

Edit: Switched IWDWS for I Have Nothing.

What is this

TipToe

Basically every single she released in the 80's only is a classic

like, there is no competition.

M-D-N-A

Quote:

Originally posted by EJQL8

Mariah: Fantasy Remix, Touch My Body.

*SCREAMING*

No one care about these two flops.

PoisonPill

Quote:

Originally posted by Entity

Mariah: No true classics in the same caliber as IWALY, Like A Virgin, Vogue, etc. The closest is probably Hero. But even that is stretching it. Many hits but no cigar.

Not when AIWFCIY is literally the standard for a timeless classic

ImmaSlave4u

People listing off those random ass songs

Madonna has the most, yes.
Whitney has IWDWS and IWALY. That's it. Bye.
Celine has MHWGO, Mariah has AIWFCIY

mdnazn

based on what?

PoisonPill

You could argue that Cher has the most:
Believe
If I Could Turn Back Time
I Got You Babe
Gypsies Tramps & Thieves
Shoop Shoop Song

M-D-N-A

Quote:

Gypsies Tramps & Thieves
Shoop Shoop Song

No one outside Europe and US know these songs exist tbh.

Teen Idle

Quote:

Originally posted by Fans

Lol I live in the UK and I've never heard them play Madonna ever

Not sure where you live (the orkney islands?) but you must have been living under a rock. Madonna was everywhere during the 00s in the UK. Even during American Life. Heart even played La Isla Bonita just an hour ago

Quote:

Originally posted by Fans

Also most people who grew up that time were not listening to that..

Well obviously since most of those songs were 20 years old... but I remember seeing them on TV music channels and hearing them at functions, as well as her contemporary hits which were huge at the time. Hung Up was unavoidable

Popboi.

Like a Virgin
Like a Prayer
Vogue
Ray of Light
Music
Hung Up (a modern classic)

+ lots of arguable classics (La Isla Bonita, Material Girl, her rendition of Don't Cry for Me Argentina...)
I would say yes.

Btw like $900 million were spent by people that went to see her perform Candy Shop, what a legendary song

HOD

Quote:

Originally posted by Entity

Madonna: Vogue, Like A Virgin, Like A Prayer

Whitney: IWALY and I Have Nothing

Mariah: No true classics in the same caliber as IWALY, Like A Virgin, Vogue, etc. The closest is probably Hero. But even that is stretching it. Many hits but no cigar.

Celine: [Insert Mariah's situation here]

Whitney and Madonna are close, but I give Madonna the edge simply for the fact that her legacy isn't highly concentrated on one era/album.

Edit: Switched IWDWS for I Have Nothing.

Let's not forget Celine's iconic hit 'My Heart Will Go On' from the Titanic soundtrack now, won't we. That one's as famous as Vogue, everybody knows it.

teresaguidice

Quote:

Originally posted by Entity

Madonna: Vogue, Like A Virgin, Like A Prayer

Whitney: IWALY and I Have Nothing

Mariah: No true classics in the same caliber as IWALY, Like A Virgin, Vogue, etc. The closest is probably Hero. But even that is stretching it. Many hits but no cigar.

Celine: [Insert Mariah's situation here]

Whitney and Madonna are close, but I give Madonna the edge simply for the fact that her legacy isn't highly concentrated on one era/album.

Edit: Switched IWDWS for I Have Nothing.

i have nothing is not one of whitney's classics. most people who aren't fans/didn't come of age in that era wouldn't recognize it today i don't think. how will i know and/or i wanna dance with somebody is though.

mariah and celine having none

all i want for christmas is you and my heart will go on are bigger classics than all of madonna's. i'd argue fantasy is a classic as well.

also to the people saying hung up is a classic in europe, i love it but that is categorically false.

Chimier

Quote:

Originally posted by teresaguidice

i have nothing is not one of whitney's classics. most people who aren't fans/didn't come of age in that era wouldn't recognize it today i don't think. how will i know and/or i wanna dance with somebody is though.

mariah and celine having none

all i want for christmas is you and my heart will go on are bigger classics than all of madonna's. i'd argue fantasy is a classic as well.

also to the people saying hung up is a classic in europe, i love it but that is categorically false.

Why do some of you like to tell lies? I Have Nothing is one of Whitney's most beloved classics. One of the most enduring pop ballads of the past two decades. The song is always covered on all these TV talent shows, for starters. Stop making baseless claims.

Bey_Rihstan

Whitney def has more.

wanderlust

Quote:

Originally posted by Fans

Lol I live in the UK and I've never heard them play Madonna ever

Madonna is the 13th most played artist just this month in the UK, and she's the 2nd female. she's that high on airplay every week, by the way. so yes, you're lying or you just listen to teen or kids radio

Tutankhamun

Quote:

Originally posted by Fans

Lol I live in the UK and I've never heard them play Madonna ever

Lies.
She's STILL the 2nd most played female artist on UK radios AT THIS MOMENT.

Rick

Whatever...