Discussion: Why is Janet superior in the pop game? - Page 7

Bey_Rihstan

Quote:

Originally posted by lonnie

This doesn't change anything though? That some young people don't know their songs is ignorance attributed to them. Young people not knowing songs by James Brown or the Beatles doesn't change anything for them, why does this change when female legends are in question?

Quote:

Originally posted by C.Damen

What experience?

Please refrain from using any kinds of fictional, anecdotal evidence.

I have no idea what pre-2008 Madonna songs teens or young adults know because there are millions upon millions of them and it's virtually impossible to ask them all.

And I don't wanna even spend time doing that.

So yea

Janet's music is more known than Madonna's among teens and young adults, though neither are rly used

C.Damen

Not this being a triple threat match between Janet, Mariah, and Madonna.

Who will reign as the Billboard Women's Champion?

PrinceMichaelFan

Quote:

Originally posted by Bey_Rihstan

ok so does RN count or not luv cus most of the mess was released in the 90's

& u can cut it with the shoulda woulda coulda mess!

Mariah > Janet in the 90's & the 00's!

Kinda not debatable.

luv Jan' tho!

Janet beat ha in the 1990s, and snatch ha in the 2000s.

Mr. Wonder

Quote:

Originally posted by Bey_Rihstan

Yea lets skip the semantics. Mariah's music PERFORMED better & she has better RECORDS as both you & I posted the receipts. not gonna argue bc the receipts have been provided

Janet only does better when it comes to top 10's & possibly weeks on the BB200

We can skip the semantics if you watch what you post from now on.

Mariah has better records? You're comparing her to the woman who has EIGHTEEN back-to-back top 10 Hot 100 hits.

C.Damen

Quote:

Originally posted by Bey_Rihstan

So yea

Janet's music is more known than Madonna's among teens and young adults, though neither are rly used

How do you know this?

And I saw that edit.

PrinceMichaelFan

Quote:

Originally posted by Bey_Rihstan

Yea lets skip the semantics. Mariah's music PERFORMED better & she has better RECORDS as both you & I posted the receipts. not gonna argue bc the receipts have been provided

Janet only does better when it comes to top 10's & possibly weeks on the BB200

How interesting that Janet has more weeks on BB200, when Mariah has 200 albums.

PrinceMichaelFan

That's The Way Love Goes >>> Any Mariah 1990s single

Billboard would agree.

Tutankhamun

Quote:

Originally posted by Bey_Rihstan

So yea

Janet's music is more known than Madonna's among teens and young adults, though neither are rly used

The delusion.

Bey_Rihstan

Quote:

Originally posted by Mr. Wonder

We can skip the semantics if you watch what you post from now on.

Mariah has better records? You're comparing her to the woman who has EIGHTEEN back-to-back top 10 Hot 100 hits.

& like I said...

That's really the only thing Janet can touch Mariah in! like.... am I arguing with a brick wall or what

Quote:

Originally posted by C.Damen

How do you know this?

And I saw that edit.

Yea don't care what u saw!

I'm right & you're wrong & that's kinda THAT!

Quote:

Originally posted by PrinceMichaelFan

How interesting that Janet has more weeks on BB200, when Mariah has 200 albums.

I said Possibly luv

But I just checked &.....

Mariah wins there too!

Bey_Rihstan

Quote:

Originally posted by Tutankhamun

The delusion.

d

Mr. Wonder

Quote:

Originally posted by Bey_Rihstan

& like I said...

That's really the only thing Janet can touch Mariah in! like.... am I arguing with a brick wall or what

And Janet's overall chart RECORDS are arguably better than Mariah's. She has Hot 100 #1s in three separate decades. She has BB200 #1 albums across four decades. She has [overall] #1 singles spanning four decades. Control - janet. are chart juggernauts.

Like....

PrinceMichaelFan

Quote:

Originally posted by Mr. Wonder

And Janet's overall chart RECORDS are arguably better than Mariah's. She has Hot 100 #1s in three separate decades. She has BB200 #1 albums across four decades. She has [overall] #1 singles spanning four decades. Control - janet. are chart juggernauts.

Like....

Snatched.

Bey_Rihstan

Quote:

Originally posted by Mr. Wonder

And Janet's overall chart RECORDS are arguably better than Mariah's. She has Hot 100 #1s in three separate decades. She has BB200 #1 albums across four decades. She has [overall] #1 singles spanning four decades. Control - janet. are chart juggernauts.

Like....

cool

Anyway Mariah >

C.Damen

Quote:

Originally posted by Bey_Rihstan

Yea don't care what u saw!

I'm right & you're wrong & that's kinda THAT!

But you should though.

And no you are not correct, my dear.

Bey_Rihstan

Quote:

Originally posted by C.Damen

But you should though.

And no you are not correct, my dear.

U gonna tell me what old Madonna songs are used by young ppl or what

PrinceMichaelFan

Poor Bey-Rihstan

C.Damen

The fact people in here are arguing over who's chart statistics are better when in reality people in the real world can honestly care less.

Mr. Wonder

Quote:

Originally posted by Bey_Rihstan

cool

Anyway Mariah >

And here you are in a Janet thread.

And Mariah is cute, I like her, but this is Janet we're discussing here.

C.Damen

Quote:

Originally posted by Bey_Rihstan

U gonna tell me what old Madonna songs are used by young ppl or what

How on Earth would I know that?

I don't know every single young person on this planet and neither do you or anyone else in this thread.

Therefore your request is null and void.

HandsOn

Quote:

Originally posted by Humoresque

And none of them want to admit that Janet DID influence their faves to some degree. When Britney went sexy on the Britney album, when Christina did it on Stripped, when Selena Gomez whispered in a t-shirt, all of these moments owe a debt to janet. more than any other album.

Yes! Let them know!