Gaga is talented, but Beyoncé outclasses her in the same way that prime Mariah outclasses, say, Ariana – clearly and in every category.
Range: There is no comparison, Beyoncé has stronger low notes, can belt much better and more freely as they ascend the scale, and completely outclasses Gaga in head voice (both in terms of range, resonance, and tonal quality).
Power: Gaga does not project her notes as well as Beyoncé does, I mean, I could never see Gaga belting an F5 and overpowering Jennifer Hudson of all people (or even matching her in volume), while Beyoncé can do so. Beyoncé always has a much more even, pleasant mix, while when Gaga tries to sound powerful she is usually forcing the notes out, especially on Joanne.
Agility: Another non-comparison, it’s not even worth going into detail.
Furthermore, even Gaga’s “greatest” vocal feat, the Sound of Music tribute which her fans post constantly, contains nothing out of the ordinary for Beyoncé. Gaga could never have recorded Love on Top, could not replicate Beyoncé’s renditions of Listen, nor could she attempt to imitate even half of Beyoncé’s melismatic feats. In other words, Beyoncé can do everything Gaga can do, but the opposite isn’t true
The only cases for Gaga being better are relatively flimsy arguments like “Gaga always sings live!” (so does that make Taylor a better vocalist than Mariah/Celine/Whitney?), “Gaga is more versatile because she sang dance pop, jazz, and whatever Joanne is!” (Giving me “Christina is extremely versatile because she sings pop, blues, hip hop!” teas, when we all know she screamed and warbled the same way over different instrumentals), and “Gaga has a better tone” (highly subjective, I for one find her recent tone extremely unpleasant and artificial).
Gaga is a solid B- Grade vocalist, perhaps a comparison to Adele who has a similar vocal range and capabilities to her would be more accurate. And yes, the OP’s agenda is also painfully obvious, but we all know both are infinitely more talented than whoever he stans for.
both are better than your fav who doesnt write her own songs and is mediocre at best during live (and tbh only thing shes good at is tapping her vagina)
Gaga is talented, but Beyoncé outclasses her in the same way that prime Mariah outclasses, say, Ariana – clearly and in every category.
Range: There is no comparison, Beyoncé has stronger low notes, can belt much better and more freely as they ascend the scale, and completely outclasses Gaga in head voice (both in terms of range, resonance, and tonal quality).
Power: Gaga does not project her notes as well as Beyoncé does, I mean, I could never see Gaga belting an F5 and overpowering Jennifer Hudson of all people (or even matching her in volume), while Beyoncé can do so. Beyoncé always has a much more even, pleasant mix, while when Gaga tries to sound powerful she is usually forcing the notes out, especially on Joanne.
Agility: Another non-comparison, it’s not even worth going into detail.
Furthermore, even Gaga’s “greatest” vocal feat, the Sound of Music tribute which her fans post constantly, contains nothing out of the ordinary for Beyoncé. Gaga could never have recorded Love on Top, could not replicate Beyoncé’s renditions of Listen, nor could she attempt to imitate even half of Beyoncé’s melismatic feats. In other words, Beyoncé can do everything Gaga can do, but the opposite isn’t true
The only cases for Gaga being better are relatively flimsy arguments like “Gaga always sings live!” (so does that make Taylor a better vocalist than Mariah/Celine/Whitney?), “Gaga is more versatile because she sang dance pop, jazz, and whatever Joanne is!” (Giving me “Christina is extremely versatile because she sings pop, blues, hip hop!” teas, when we all know she screamed and warbled the same way over different instrumentals), and “Gaga has a better tone” (highly subjective, I for one find her recent tone extremely unpleasant and artificial).
Gaga is a solid B- Grade vocalist, perhaps a comparison to Adele who has a similar vocal range and capabilities to her would be more accurate. And yes, the OP’s agenda is also painfully obvious, but we all know both are infinitely more talented than whoever he stans for.
Stefani is easily more vocally skilled than Ms. Adkins, better "manipulation" of the voice color, better sense of pitch, support, resonance, etc. Besides that, you took the words out of my mouth.
Gaga is talented, but Beyoncé outclasses her in the same way that prime Mariah outclasses, say, Ariana – clearly and in every category.
Range: There is no comparison, Beyoncé has stronger low notes, can belt much better and more freely as they ascend the scale, and completely outclasses Gaga in head voice (both in terms of range, resonance, and tonal quality).
Power: Gaga does not project her notes as well as Beyoncé does, I mean, I could never see Gaga belting an F5 and overpowering Jennifer Hudson of all people (or even matching her in volume), while Beyoncé can do so. Beyoncé always has a much more even, pleasant mix, while when Gaga tries to sound powerful she is usually forcing the notes out, especially on Joanne.
Agility: Another non-comparison, it’s not even worth going into detail.
Furthermore, even Gaga’s “greatest” vocal feat, the Sound of Music tribute which her fans post constantly, contains nothing out of the ordinary for Beyoncé. Gaga could never have recorded Love on Top, could not replicate Beyoncé’s renditions of Listen, nor could she attempt to imitate even half of Beyoncé’s melismatic feats. In other words, Beyoncé can do everything Gaga can do, but the opposite isn’t true
The only cases for Gaga being better are relatively flimsy arguments like “Gaga always sings live!” (so does that make Taylor a better vocalist than Mariah/Celine/Whitney?), “Gaga is more versatile because she sang dance pop, jazz, and whatever Joanne is!” (Giving me “Christina is extremely versatile because she sings pop, blues, hip hop!” teas, when we all know she screamed and warbled the same way over different instrumentals), and “Gaga has a better tone” (highly subjective, I for one find her recent tone extremely unpleasant and artificial).
Gaga is a solid B- Grade vocalist, perhaps a comparison to Adele who has a similar vocal range and capabilities to her would be more accurate. And yes, the OP’s agenda is also painfully obvious, but we all know both are infinitely more talented than whoever he stans for.
Bey is "technically" a better vocalist but her voice is emotionless and boring; Gagas voice is full of emotion, which I think is more important than being able to belt a high note or whatever,
So my vote goes to Gaga
Gaga is talented, but Beyoncé outclasses her in the same way that prime Mariah outclasses, say, Ariana – clearly and in every category.
Range: There is no comparison, Beyoncé has stronger low notes, can belt much better and more freely as they ascend the scale, and completely outclasses Gaga in head voice (both in terms of range, resonance, and tonal quality).
Power: Gaga does not project her notes as well as Beyoncé does, I mean, I could never see Gaga belting an F5 and overpowering Jennifer Hudson of all people (or even matching her in volume), while Beyoncé can do so. Beyoncé always has a much more even, pleasant mix, while when Gaga tries to sound powerful she is usually forcing the notes out, especially on Joanne.
Agility: Another non-comparison, it’s not even worth going into detail.
Furthermore, even Gaga’s “greatest” vocal feat, the Sound of Music tribute which her fans post constantly, contains nothing out of the ordinary for Beyoncé. Gaga could never have recorded Love on Top, could not replicate Beyoncé’s renditions of Listen, nor could she attempt to imitate even half of Beyoncé’s melismatic feats. In other words, Beyoncé can do everything Gaga can do, but the opposite isn’t true
The only cases for Gaga being better are relatively flimsy arguments like “Gaga always sings live!” (so does that make Taylor a better vocalist than Mariah/Celine/Whitney?), “Gaga is more versatile because she sang dance pop, jazz, and whatever Joanne is!” (Giving me “Christina is extremely versatile because she sings pop, blues, hip hop!” teas, when we all know she screamed and warbled the same way over different instrumentals), and “Gaga has a better tone” (highly subjective, I for one find her recent tone extremely unpleasant and artificial).
Gaga is a solid B- Grade vocalist, perhaps a comparison to Adele who has a similar vocal range and capabilities to her would be more accurate. And yes, the OP’s agenda is also painfully obvious, but we all know both are infinitely more talented than whoever he stans for.
