I wonder if this means they basically recorded a song for Gaga and handled it to her or they wrote it together and he just decided to record it as well.

Is it too late to add this in the This Was 2015 rate? I wanna give it a 1

its good

This instrumental is so much better. Wish they kept it.

I really like it

I feel like Gaga brings more emotion to it.

wish they collabed

I like this one better than the original.

Gaga's version is much better

This song is definitely a highlight. She should have worked with him more

this is literally 10x better than the original

King.

can't believe meghan trainor is ghostwriting for father john misty now

kay this is better than the album version

why did she change the chorus melody into a meghan sized mess?

Better than hers.

My theory is they wrote the lyrics together or something. Then he made it into that demo and they created the song based on that template. Then again it's one of only two songs that she is not credited first in the writing. The other is perfect illusion and gaga herself has said Kevin Parker came up with the concept for that song.