How would you guys rate this season of AHS one scale from 1-10(10 being the best obviously)

IMO it's one of their best seasons in years, up there with Murder House and Asylum

I agree

I'd say around a 9. Definitely in my trinity (so far) with Murder House and Asylum.

A solid 7.
It needs more action

Yes! This **** has got me on edge. I never thought I'd see the day. I missed last night's episode though.

It's better than the last two seasons so far. I'll give it a 7/10.

A 5. Not great, but an improvement from last season.

3

I was confused to why the interracial characters' actors kept changing. Was it a flashback or something so I haven't bothered watching since then

6.

Coven = Asylum > Murder House > Roanoke > Freak Show > Hotel

Coven > Asylum > Murder House > Freak Show > Hotel > Roanoke

Its not good at all tbh.

10/10

Haven't watched it yet because the last two seasons were atrocious. Is this one actually scary? And have they toned down the ridiculousness?

9 so far, I hope they don't screw it up
In my trinity (along with Asylum and MH ofc )

Yes. I didn't like the last 2 seasons either but I love this.

It was clearly a dramatic reenactment. It even stated such, and even if it didn't, it was still painfully obvious.

Any way, I give it a 3. It's not great nor that compelling but I'll keep watching. The documentary segment takes me out of the show. Can't wait when that element is gone in ep. 5.

9. Second only to Asylum, in my opinion

(so far)

7.

It's pretty bad imo
Cliche horror elements, the fake documentary concept is tacky, bad acting.

Hoping the twist that's supposed to come 5 episodes in is worth watching 5 episodes of this faux documentary

It's pretty good. Am satisfied