first to do it correctly , anyway !!!

no one talked about Paradiso, in fact most people try to forget it exists. Kanye did do the damn thing first w/ Runaway but people hardly paid attention due to his personal drama

Bey made people care, and now she got everyone from Frank Ocean and Drake to even the lessor girls like Tove Lo making mini movies to try and keep up. stay pissed, stay bitter, it won't redact this article and it won't take away from the insurmountable impact Bey has made in the last 3 years alone on the front of audio/visual music components

Kanye & Bey
L E G E N D S

Tropico wasn't an album. It didn't even feature all the songs on the ep.
how in the hell is it a visual album?

oh nie! short film! already done!

lmao

Thanks for posting in yet another Bey thread. See you soon

well when u live in a pineapple under the sea and ur only friend is patrick star i'd imagine it's hard to get a hold of such coveted and acclaimed multimedia content like Lemonade

Gosh some of yall are bitter as ****.

NO Kanye or Lana or anybody else had the impact with a visual suprise drop like Bey. Like, I get y'all don't like it. But facts are facts, and Bey will forever remain the face of this trend. Get over IT and appreciate someone who is willing to challenge the way we consume music nowadays. Someone, whos willing to take risks.

The difference is in the showcasing and the storytelling. No one said she did it first, but most people say she did it better. No one was trying to do what Kanye was doing when he released Runaway. And THAT is the difference.

I'm not sure if you read my post correctly. Nowhere did I say that Tropico was a visual album. I said it was a short film, which is what the article is discussing. Did you even bother to understand the article you rushed to post?

I see the stans of the less fortunate artists have already arrived

Beyoncé was the first to make it a modern day trend. It's been done before, but it is now a new trend in music - along with surprise releases and releasing on Friday. You cannot be an observer of pop culture/music and deny Beyoncé's role in this...

Inventor of impact and terminator of empty seats in stadiums

Did you?

reading comprehension ha!

Unlike you I read the whole article and not just glanced over it.
And the conclusion is lana is not the first to do anything and neither is kanye.

Usher - Rhythm City >>> Tropico

Nowhere are they discussing anything or even mentioning the word short film.
And 75% of the article is about how Lemonade, Please Forgive Me and Endless premiered.

Is that not what Lana was trying to do by incorporating songs off of her album to a visual storyline? I mean, seriously, you might want to actually think before you rush to defend your favorite artist from someone who neither dislikes nor likes her, but only desires to add to the discussion. It seems like you're triggered by the smallest ounce of criticism. Grow up.

Lmao

And I clearly stated that I don't think Lana was the first to release a short film, so, no, I don't think you actually understood what you read, which isn't surprising.

And, yes, the article mentions short films/mini-movies. Read it again...more carefully this time.