MTV is one step above Buzzfeed at this point, it's sad really. At least they were honest tho

She slayed, the song is good, SHE WON.

I'm screaming at this being a bedazzled skeleton glittering in the depths of an uncanny valley

Serving failed creative writing major REALNESS

No. It honestly feels like most people wanted to like the song. We need to stop making excuses for her.

they were all spot on

omg noo delete this

They are right about this song. There is no there there.

I like how all it takes is for one person to say something, and then everyone immediately feels the need to agree. It happens almost all of the time. "What's that? You don't like it? Oh, neither do I!" It's not cute in the slightest. Not one person liking the song isn't a coincidence. Someone needs to be brave, for God's sake.

MTV has never lied about anything 💋

What a pretentious review. If they don't like it, just say you don't.

Or maybe no one likes the song?

iTunes would like to disagree with you.

This. Reading through this thread is pathetic. Like, just accept that the critics didn't like it, it's nbd

the monsters being angry at this
like these reviewers are just echoing what the majority of ATRL thinks of the song.
and y'all saying this is bc she didn't go to the VMAs lol. like if the GP isn't even here for her new song why would they have tuned in just for her . dumb logic tbh

Yikes

has she ever been received poorly on a lead single? i think critics loved JD, BR, and BTW, right? and i don't think applause got worse reviews than PI

just curious. i personally don't care what reviewers think; my opinion is the only one that matters to me. PI is good, but severely underwhelming and a little basic considering it should've been gaga's big comeback and the three producers who were on it.